4 ms·
I agree with all of this, but I will pick a nit here: > There are plenty of us who think that the "Paradox of Tolerance" is mistaken, rather than truth. It may
by throwaway894345 6y ago
I agree with all of this, but I will pick a nit here:
> There are plenty of us who think that the "Paradox of Tolerance" is mistaken, rather than truth. It may sound reasonable, but it is used in practice to define ideas we don't like as intolerant, and then exclude those who hold those ideas.
If they've changed the definition of "tolerance" to proxy their ingroup, are they actually talking about the Paradox of Tolerance? Or are they observing a new "paradox": 'progressives don't tolerate who they don't tolerate'? I ask because the distinction seems interesting to me; not trying to be pedantic.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYou could argue that they're not actually talking about the Paradox of Tolerance. (See philwelch's comment for what the real Paradox of Tolerance is, according to Popper.) You could even argue that they're not actually talking about the Paradox of Tolerance as defined by themselves. But at that point, the Paradox of Tolerance becomes useless, because whether it's being applied correctly or wrongly depends on the honesty and correct judgment of the one applying it. And it's really tempting to use it without honesty or correct judgment, all the while claiming that your side is the good guys.