3 ms·
It would probably go faster if they just concentrated on length, area, volume, and mass. With those you can make a good case for switching because we routinely
by tzs 6y ago
It would probably go faster if they just concentrated on length, area, volume, and mass. With those you can make a good case for switching because we routinely deal with quantities of those units over a range of several orders of magnitude.
That means we regularly have use of smaller or larger units than the base unit for each, and in the metric system all those smaller or larger units are related to each other and the base units by powers of 10.
That fits well with our decimal number system, and makes conversions between units nearly trivial. If you have, say, kilometers and you want millimeters it is a lot easier than if you have miles and want inches.
You can make the case that we should switch to metric for length, area, volume, and mass because it is better and because it is used by almost all of the rest of the world.
With temperature, on the other hand, we do not generally deal with a large range, and generally don't use larger or smaller units. We just stick to the base unit (C or F).
The only significant differences between C and F are the size of their degrees and where the 0 point is. Historically, C set its 0 point at the freezing point of water and the degree size indirectly by setting 100 as the boiling point of water. F used the temperature of a specified eutectic mixture to set 0 and tried to set 96 as human body temperature.
(Actually, C originally set 0 at the boiling point of water and 100 at the freezing point, but that was fairly quickly reversed).
F came before C by about 20 years. People decided they liked using freezing and boiling of water as their reference points.
What should have happened is that F should have simply been redefined so that its reference points were freezing of water at 32 and boiling at 212, keeping the same size degree. That would be compatible with the old F. There was no need to come up with a new degree size to switch to a freezing/boiling of water basis.
So because C does not have any inherent superiority over F, unlike other metric units compared to Imperial units, the case for switching comes down to pretty much only that it is what most of the rest of the world uses.
Furthermore, F actually has some advantages. F's smaller degree size means many times an integer temperature is adequate where you might need to add a decimal place with C. On F, 0 to 100 is a pretty good match for the weather in most of the US. That would be about -17 to 38 in C.
So it is hard to make the case to most people in the US that they gain anything tangible by switching to C, let alone gain enough to be worth the switching cost.
Thus, I think US metrification efforts need to table temperature, and just work on the others.
- pmiller2 6y agoI'm surprised you were able to come up with any way in which F is at all better than C. But, I don't think it's a great one, given that 0.5 degrees C is so close to 1 degree F. Half degrees aren't that tough to use.
- shmerl 6y agoI'd simplify the above. It's hard to make any argument for switching, because it's annoying to change habits. That's about it. Even if it offers advantages, some will be reluctant, because of the above habit issue. So they should just push metrication, period, instead of dragging it for decades. Other countries did it successfully including for temperature, so how is it a bigger problem in US than for them?