5 ms·
> HTTP/2 can only bring advantages if you actually go all the way to push/bundle resources into responses Compared to well-optimized HTTP/1 (e.g. using minifie
by derefr 6y ago
> HTTP/2 can only bring advantages if you actually go all the way to push/bundle resources into responses
Compared to well-optimized HTTP/1 (e.g. using minified CSS and sprite-sheets), sure. Compared to most HTTP/1 deployments, though: no. HTTP/2 gives you tons of advantages "for free" that you need build-time processes to attain in HTTP/1. With HTTP/2, you can do "the naive thing" that'd you'd have done on the 1995 Web in Notepad, and it'll be the optimal thing.
Also, HTTP/2 means less OS packet-switching overhead server-side if you have ancillary connections (e.g. websockets) open against the host, since those also get muxed into the same carrier socket.
Also, mobile clients wake up less, because there's only one TCP socket to do idle-keepalive on.
HTTP/2 also means that TCP's Nagling has more to work with, and so is less likely to end up needing to waste bandwidth on emitting many undersized packets—it can just pack N short requests into the same TCP jumbo frame, since they're all going to the same place.
I would also point out an indirect "advantage": HTTP/2 makes it cheaper to serve ads proxied through the first-party host (as HTTP/2 flows) than for the client to hit the third-party ad servers directly. People can still block the ads/trackers either way, but served inline to the origin like this, the people who don't block ads, will get a better experience.
- secondcoming 6y agoWhat have CSS and sprite-sheets go to do with the HTTP protocol?
- tannhaeuser 6y agoI agree these things can be useful, but again none of these come out of the box (if I haven't overlooked or misunderstood something). Including "doing the naive thing"; I mean how do you expect your web server to automatically push CSS or SVG sprites/fonts unless you're relying on the server to intercept/parse your HTML for delivery-time optimizations a la PageSpeed and make heuristic scheduling decisions? Unless you're putting in the effort to optimize your payloads you will just result in as many roundtrips with HTTP/1.1 + keep-alive.
- derefr 6y agoWeb browsers are limited in the number of concurrent socket connections they'll open to a given origin. This matters not-at-all in HTTP/2, since everything is going over a single socket; while mattering quite a lot in HTTP/1, since dependent resources being loaded in parallel must be loaded on separate sockets. If you only have six parallel sockets to work with, then if your page is, say, an image gallery, then the Javascript file that makes it work (loaded at the bottom of the body) might be blocked waiting behind the loading of e.g. some large image higher up in the body. The previous requests need to entirely finish (= a round trip) before the next requests on the same socket can start. Keep-alive does nothing to fix that. HTTP/1.1 pipelining partially mitigates this, allowing the client to "queue up" a list of all the dependent resources it wants from each socket; but it suffers from head-of-line blocking. Which sounds like some arcane thing, but in practice it means that big things might block the loading of small things. (The browser doesn't know how big things are, so it can't effectively schedule them; and the server must dumbly queue results up in the same order the client requested them, because that's the only way the HTTP pipeline's implicit flow sequence counters will match up.) HTTP/2 is a full mitigation for this problem, since—even without a heuristic "prioritization strategy" for the delivery of dependent-resource flows—the "oblivious" strategy is still a good one: if you attempt to deliver all the resources in the queue concurrently; and you do so by delivering one fixed-size chunk of each flow per iteration, in a round-robin fashion; then you'll end up finishing delivery of resources smallest-to-largest—which means you'll usually deliver the most-critical resources first, no matter where in the dependent-resource queue they started. Or, in short: HTTP/1.0 = O(N) required roundtrips for a page with N resources. HTTP/1.1 with pipelining = O(1) required roundtrips for a page with N resources (followed by O(N) bytes streamed half-duplex), but the page can still take nearly the same amount of time to become interactive as if it were O(N) roundtrips, because of effectively worst-case scheduling. HTTP/1.2 = O(1) RTTs + O(N) half-duplex bytes for N resources, loading "intelligently" such that the page becomes interactive in O(log N) time.
- tannhaeuser 6y agoI really appreciate your going into these details, but I still don't understand the "oblivious" strategy thing which supposedly improves baseline performance OOTB when the criterion is the time to first render of above-the-fold content given otherwise same conditions. You say the effect of delivering all resources concurrently is that "the most-critical resources [are delivered first], no matter where in the dependent-resource queue they started". But this isn't proven; it's just a different heuristic to apply to traffic shaping assuming small resources are needed early vs assuming dependent resources (+ HTML markup itself) are loaded asynchronously in the order the browser parses an HTML DOM (the default behaviour, and the one authors can influence directly). You're not magically increasing the bandwidth by multiplexing so something has to give.
- KaiserPro 6y agoHTTP2 fails for mobile clients. it shoves everything down a single TCP connection. This means that if you loose a packet (and 4g is lossy) it stalls the _entire_ queue. Instead of addressing the main complaint (that multiplexing everything down a single TCP connection is a fundamentally stupid idea) they come up with an entirely _new_ protocol. It also fails to understand what HTTP2 has turned into: a file transport protocol, with some RPC built in. So, instead of optimising for file transfer, a control layer, and a communication/serialisation layer, they came up with a horrid mush that is http3. (or the googlenet)
- derefr 6y agoTo be clear, it's not like there are any HTTP/2-only servers in the world. HTTP/2 is something a client connection upgrades to. One might think of HTTP/2 and HTTP/3 not precisely as versions of HTTP, but rather as variants—HTTP/2 is "optimized binary HTTP, fixed-station profile" and HTTP/3 is "optimized binary HTTP, mobile-station profile." (Mind you, they are versions relative to each-other, because HTTP/3 is strictly better at doing what HTTP/2 does than HTTP/2 is, so there's no reason to use HTTP/2 if you have HTTP/3.) But as I was saying: nobody forces mobile devices to use HTTP/2; and by-and-large, they don't. HTTP/1.1 still has its use-cases; neither HTTP/2 nor HTTP/3 was designed to obviate HTTP/1.1's entire set of use-cases. You know how SSH has sub-protocols, e.g. SFTP? HTTP/2 and HTTP/3 are to HTTP/1.1, as SFTP is to SSH. It's a mode you can put the connection into, that will optimize it for a certain profile of use-cases. No more, no less. (You know what else is a mode you can put HTTP/1.1 into? Websockets! Again, a complementary use-case.) > So, instead of optimising for file transfer, a control layer, and a communication/serialisation layer, they came up with a horrid mush that is http3. (or the googlenet) If you think you're so smart, write an RFC (or even just, build a reference server) that's competitive in production performance for its use-cases over similar links. There comes a point when explicit OSI-style encapsulating layering becomes an active hindrance; and for the use-case of "a server serving a million concurrent requests"—the FAANG-scale problem—they passed that point long ago. Yes, we mere mortal client users and backend developers might not find such use-cases relevant; but take the perspective of e.g. an internet backbone ops engineer. By volume, most of the traffic going around the Internet goes to these sites. Optimizing just the traffic going to these sites—with a special protocol clients only use when speaking to these sites—makes the whole Internet faster, by reducing in size the huge blob of bandwidth-contention the requests to these few sites create. Also, a design hint, if you actually want to try to build something competitive to HTTP/3: most of the problem being solved by HTTP/3 is that certain things are known to be optimal, but despite that, nobody can just force their corporate overlords to mandate a switch to those things right away. So HTTP/3 needs to be optimized for the case where you do the most fundamentally-performant things (e.g. using zero-copy binary serialization protocols like Capn Proto from a process with direct userland Ethernet access); and also for the cases where you do less fundamentally-performant things (like generating and streaming a JSONL or CSV stream line-by-line as the output rows gets computed by an in-process dataflow engine.) One might call HTTP/3 an arbitrary custom protocol, that happens to have semantics such that it can be downgraded to HTTP/1.1 by a link-to-link proxy. And that is a hard constraint to optimize under.