2 ms·
This piece is ridiculous. Mainly: > What matters more in an ideological war, though, is influence, and that is why I do believe that ByteDance’s continued owne
by crazygringo 6y ago
This piece is ridiculous. Mainly:
> What matters more in an ideological war, though, is influence, and that is why I do believe that ByteDance’s continued ownership of TikTok is unacceptable.
What's implied but unsaid here is that somehow the CCP is going to fill TikTok with political propaganda that... a bunch of teens are going to somehow become influenced by? Sorry, but that's just completely far-fetched. Facebook is something to be concerned about, with people sharing political stories, memes, etc. But TikTok? A bunch of funny videos? There's nothing that could be further from ideology.
> Perhaps the most powerful argument against taking any sort of action is that we aren’t China, and isn’t blocking TikTok something that China would do?
Yes, this is precisely why we don't need to do this. We're better than China. Things like freedom of speech, democracy, and the free market set a moral example to the world. Once we start censoring things, we lose that moral leadership. (And sure you can argue all you want about our declining moral leadership and the state of our democracy, but let's not make it even worse, shall we?)
> If China is on the offensive against liberalism not only within its borders but within ours, it is in liberalism’s interest to cut off a vector that has taken root precisely because it is so brilliantly engineered to give humans exactly what they want.
Isn't every product trying to be brilliantly engineered to give customers exactly what they want? All this boils down to is, it's a good app, so let's kill it. Again, totally opposite the American values of competition, the free market, and consumers.
Sorry, but there is absolutely zero logic in this analysis.
- narrator 6y agoTikTok users flooded the Trump rally with fake ticket requests. https://nypost.com/2020/06/21/tiktok-campaigns-ensure-hundreds-of-unused-seats-at-trump-tulsa-rally/ https://nypost.com/2020/06/21/tiktok-campaigns-ensure-hundre... The plausible deniability is easy. No one will ever find out if it was specially promoted. They could just throw up their hands and say that it all happened all by itself. The algorithm is a mystery and a trade secret! U.S Teens are making "I Love China" videos on TikTok. https://www.recruitmentnewsuk.co.uk/2020/05/28/why-us-teens-on-tiktok-are-making-i-love-china-videos/ https://www.recruitmentnewsuk.co.uk/2020/05/28/why-us-teens-... The algorithm could interfere to remove any pro-Trump or anti-China TikToks and noone would be the wiser. There is zero transparency. The Chinese government can lend these institutions billions forever and undercut rivals and overpay programmers if it buys them political influence. Speaking of a free market in ideas. 90% of the U.S media is owned by 5 companies. I think a good idea would be to reverse the Telecommunications Act of 1996 which allowed for massive TV and Radio consolidation. Local radio was actually good in the late 80s and early 90s and new music styles were discovered and promoted by disk jockeys on local stations. After 96, the conglomerates bought up all the radio stations and IMHO, popular music more or less froze in place with just the names of the bands rotating.
- crazygringo 6y agoAnd all sorts of nonsense happens on Facebook. But TikTok is almost infinitely less political than Facebook. The Trump rally thing was a prank that was widely publicized on the internet. And the "I love China" videos seem to be a joke too. You're going to find a little bit of everything on every platform. The idea that TikTok is somehow pushing Chinese ideology remains completely unfounded and baseless. It's pure imagination and conjecture. If it ever does, it will be obvious and action can be taken then. But until it does, banning something like TikTok is simply blatantly anticompetitive and stooping to China's types of censorship. Again, we're better than that.