4 ms·
> that would likely have no impact to policy even if they were demonstrably true because the driving factor is human safety and not efficacy or ease of teaching
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> that would likely have no impact to policy even if they were demonstrably true because the driving factor is human safety and not efficacy or ease of teaching.
Why would it have "no impact to policy"?
Let's imagine for a moment that we discovered remote learning was 100% ineffective for everyone. Students came out of remote learning programs with no more knowledge than they did going in. Should we:
A) Continue with remote learning anyway, because in-person classes are unsafe.
B) Stop remote learning, and accept that students will have to put their educations on hold for a year, despite all the implications that will have.
Personally, I think option B is the obvious choice. There’s no point in doing anything if students don’t benefit.
Okay, now let's say that remote learning was only 50% effective, or 60%. Is option A now the right answer? Putting everyone’s education on hold is going to have lots of dire consequences—but, is it worse than educating them inadequately? What does that mean for the next generation of high schoolers entering college, or college students entering the workforce?
Alternately, perhaps the correct conclusion is that we really, really do need to reopen schools this fall. Why is so much of the country currently focused on reopening hair salons and outdoor restaurants while keeping schools closed? Maybe it should be the other way around—maybe schools are the most essential service, and we need to reopen them ASAP at the expense of other kinds of businesses.
- darkerside 6y agoI think you'd agree that any claim it's 100% ineffective is a straw man, and was just for purposes of the example. FWICT, most policy is being set with a baked-in assumption that remote learning is somewhat less effective than in-person learning. As I said, I don't see what the article does to add to that discussion, although it does possibly queue up a discussion on how we could make it better.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]