8 ms·
> They should have called it "CoPilot" [rather than "AutoPilot"] Huh but a co-pilot is much more capable than an auto-pilot system. An auto-pilot mostly keeps
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> They should have called it "CoPilot" [rather than "AutoPilot"]
Huh but a co-pilot is much more capable than an auto-pilot system. An auto-pilot mostly keeps you level, going the right speed, and pointing in the right direction, and can do some limited landing and things.
That sounds to me exactly like what Tesla's system does?
A co-pilot is a human who can take complete control from you for the rest of the whole flight and deal with any emergency or unexpected situation. The co-pilot is much more advanced than the autopilot.
- catalogia 6y agoThe problem with this line of reasoning is that the general public has an inaccurate understanding of what airplane autopilots are capable of. The belief that modern airline pilots just push a button to turn on the plane then take a nap until the plane lands is widespread. In naming their system after a system the public has a poor understanding of, Tesla is being misleading.
- aaomidi 6y agoTesla conveniently used a word where it actually means something far simpler than what the general public knows it to mean. Tesla knew this but they did it anyway because $$$.
- chrisseaton 6y agoHowever good the public think autopilots are, I'm sure they don't think they're more capable than a co-pilot!
- catalogia 6y agoI agree that 'co-pilot' would also be a very misleading name. I think they should avoid these sort of airplane analogies entirely and just describe features as they are. E.g. call lane assist "lane assist", call adaptive cruise control "adaptive cruise control." These are terms that reasonably convey what the systems do, without exploiting the public's general ignorance of how airplanes work.
- FabHK 6y agoEtymologically though, the co-pilot is pilot along with you and supports you, while the auto-pilot is a pilot by itself, independently (dare I say: autonomously). "Autopilot" remains a very misleading term in the car context.
- chrisseaton 6y agoNo you have it the wrong way around. A co-pilot is equal to a pilot. An autopilot automates just some functions of piloting.
- FabHK 6y agoThat’s my point: what happens to be the case in actual aviation is in some sense the opposite of the words‘ connotations. So, they’re very misleading terms. Which becomes problematic when marketing a powerful, but limited technology to the mass market.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LoSboccacc 6y ago"All Tesla cars come with Full Self Driving Capability" they even replaced - hardware to - capability to be even more ambiguous.
- cjhopman 6y agoIt is insane that that is allowed. I'm not sure if it is more or less insane that there are Tesla fans that would defend that.
- rsynnott 6y agoWell, per the article, it is NOT allowed, at least in Germany. I have been kind of amazed how hands off the advertising and road safety regulators have been with Tesla so far, tho.
- _lmm8 6y agoIts nice to make semantic distinctions, but thats not how most of the population (people buying the car) think of it.
- close04 6y agoThey should simply call it "Driver Assistance" which is very appropriate for such systems.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIt's the same thing as putting "fat free" on the Twizzlers. It's technically true which means they can get away with it. Except that that probably kills more people than "autopilot" ever will.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoIt's not food companies' fault that the English word “fat” has multiple meanings and is the normal word for several of them.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoYou don't think they're intentionally using that word for precisely that reason?
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoBut there's no other commonly-used word for it!
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago"Sugar free" (oops, not true) "No calories" (not true again) There are a hundred ways to say that something won't cause you to gain weight. They chose the one that sounds like it means that even though it doesn't, because it also has a different meaning which is technically true.
- rhino369 6y agoBut autopilot in a plane doesn't require the pilot to take over in a split second. Keeping you level, at the right speed, in the right direction, etc. is enough to keep the plane safe. Pilots have tens of seconds to reorient themselves to avert any disaster. In contrast, Telsa "autopilot" requires constant vigilance since you might have to take over without any warning.
- outworlder 6y ago> But autopilot in a plane doesn't require the pilot to take over in a split second. That's a very broad statement. Autopilots can disengage at any time and you are supposed to take control pretty much immediately.
- random314 6y agoLike the op said, split second takeover is not required in a flight autopilot
- OnlyForF1 6y agoYes it is... Especially when the autopilot causes the aircraft to enter a dangerous configuration.
- bdonlan 6y agoWhere immediately is generally measured in seconds (with the exception of perhaps autoland). Normally the autopilot will have the plane trimmed at all times, so the plane will continue flying its current course for some time without control inputs.
- ogre_codes 6y ago> In contrast, Telsa "autopilot" requires constant vigilance since you might have to take over without any warning. Neither version eliminates the need for the pilot/ driver to cease situational control. Pilots have absolutely flown into the side of mountains while on autopilot. (Ironically called "Controlled flight into terrain"). The big difference between the two is in an aircraft there is less to collide with when the pilot screws up. The big problem isn't whether the two are actually similar or not, the problem is most people assume that autopilot on an aircraft does a lot more than what it actually does. In most cases, autopilot in an aircraft maintains heading and altitude, that's pretty much it. Adding to all the confusion is the fact that "Autopilot" in aircraft can mean a giant pile of different things, but the term was originally coined quite a while ago to refer to basic altitude/ bearing hold.
- dkonofalski 6y agoYou're transposing airplane terminology with automobile terminology. In a car, the co-pilot is typically someone that sits in the passenger seat and functions only as an additional set of eyes. They can't take complete control over the vehicle from that spot. Cars, unlike airplanes, don't have two sets of full controls.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> You're transposing airplane terminology with automobile terminology. Well yeah... transposing terminology is how an analogy is supposed to work. And I didn't pick the analogies - Tesla did and then you proposed another flying analogy! > In a car, the co-pilot is typically someone that sits in the passenger seat and functions only as an additional set of eyes. Do you mean a co-driver? Like in a rally car? I've never seen that called a 'co-pilot' before. If you don't want to confuse with aeroplanes, why didn't you suggest 'co-driver'?
- arrosenberg 6y agoThis comment seems to pretty much ignore the lingua franca of American drivers. Transposing terminology only works to the extent that the public actually understands how an airplane autopilot functions, which they don't. Plenty of people refer to their front seat passenger as a co-pilot or navigator, but I've never heard anyone call their passenger "co-driver".
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Plenty of people refer to their front seat passenger as a co-pilot or navigator Can you use that in a sentence? Like 'will you be my co-pilot while I drive to the store?' I don't see it to be honest.
- arrosenberg 6y ago"I don't know exactly where the turn is, I need you to co-pilot."