3 ms·
To people who haven't tried keeping track of their personal finances using double-entry bookkeeping, I strongly recommend it. It's not just about reducing erro
by kqr 6y ago
To people who haven't tried keeping track of their personal finances using double-entry bookkeeping, I strongly recommend it.
It's not just about reducing error (although it does that really well too.) It's also about increasing transparency, for two reasons: it makes many things explicit that would otherwise be easy to hide, perhaps by accident; it also provides very strong support for querying your finances in various ways.
Whenever I'm budgeting for something (a project among friends, the wedding with my wife, and so on) I always try to start out "simpler" but I also always end up doing something like double-entry bookkeeping because all other "simpler" solutions make it very hard to figure out where money is actually coming from and where it is going.
This is as good a place as any to start: https://plaintextaccounting.org/ https://plaintextaccounting.org/
- xur17 6y agoI currently use a spreadsheet to track my expenses, and have looked into moving to something like plaintextaccounting in the past, but I struggle to figure out how to migrate over all of my existing data. Any suggestions?
- kqr 6y agoDo what the accountants do: close the old books and open new ones. Initialise relevant accounts with sums from the old books. Edit: that said, I've found spreadsheets to be some of the most convenient ways to do high-level double entry. Just so you don't assume you need to learn a new tool to do it.
- Metus 6y agoCould you expand on the benefits of double-entry bookkeeping, beyond reducing errors? Personally I am looking into it, because the run-of-the-mill personal finance software applications can't even deal with the fact that paying off a credit card statement is not income and expense, but a mere change between assets and liabilities. Or buying some stock is not an expense, but a change between two types of assets. And so on. However, the run-of-the-mill software is a bit better with categorizing things and integrating with other applications. Currently, I am looking for - Connecting PDFs or images as invoices with transactions - Marking transactions as relevant for my tax income statement - Estimating my tax return in advance and some more I can't think of off the top of my head. What weirds me out, is that everyone has to deal with personal finances, yet there isn't a single personal finance app that deals with everyone's situation. Do I massively underestimate the complexity of the problem domain?
- holri 6y agoGnucash does most things you mention.
- Chirael 6y agoIs Gnucash closer to Quicken or Quickbooks? I wish I had started with Quickbooks even for my personal finances, years ago, but I used Quicken instead :( My impression was that Gnucash was meant as an open source version of Quicken which would be much less attractive as it hides the true double-entry bookkeeping going on underneath.
- jsmith99 6y agoGnucash doesn't hide the double entries; on the contrary, it shows little else.
- Chirael 6y agoThanks; that actually makes me want to check it out more. I appreciate the info.
- ericbarrett 6y agoIt's closer to Quickbooks. Gnucash's interface is stripped-down but fairly friendly, focused directly on the chart of accounts and registers, with lots of keyboard shortcuts and relatively little unintuitive behavior. It runs fine for me on MacOS 10.14; the developers keep it quite up to date. It's very powerful and I believe you could run nearly any SMB on it, much less personal finances. That said, I haven't touched QB in a minute, and never their online offering, so I'd love to hear how it compares from somebody who's used both. (Not specifically to parent:) You will need to know double-entry bookkeeping to use Gnucash. While there is no in-app tutorial and little hand-holding (by default the "Debit" and "Credit" columns of the register are given friendly names), there is an excellent Tutorials and Concepts guide https://gnucash.org/viewdoc.phtml?rev=4&lang=C&doc=guide https://gnucash.org/viewdoc.phtml?rev=4&lang=C&doc=guide that starts from first principles on basic accounting, and has tons of examples of how to enter various transactions. I was very impressed going through it, as a layman; it's a hidden gem and better than 90% of the "accounting tutorial" websites out there.
- cosmodisk 6y agoI did run micro enterprise on Ebay for a bit. At some point I wanted to know how much money I'm actually making after all the fees, envelopes,stams,and etc. It took me quite some effort to arrive to a meaningful figure.This was a good lesson on how a small business could go sideways very quickly without not knowing the basics. These things are easy to do but not doing them can become very hard very quickly.