5 ms·
You raise a very, very important (and debated) point. (disclosure: I was at AWS 2008-2014, and VMware's cloud business 2014-2016; opinions my own, no disclosur
by simonebrunozzi 6y ago
You raise a very, very important (and debated) point.
(disclosure: I was at AWS 2008-2014, and VMware's cloud business 2014-2016; opinions my own, no disclosure of secrets, etc etc)
Most SLAs only indemnify you for the paltry infrastructure costs in relation to the downtime or accident.
Few SLAs are more extensive, covering for example data loss.
AFAIK, no SLA exists that extensively cover such type of loss. (perhaps with the exception of heavily customized contracts, sometimes part of a military contractor deal, where numbers are out of this world and there's huge margins for clauses and exceptions everywhere).
They don't exist for two reasons, IMHO:
1) it's very complicated to define metrics related to the amount to be indemnified, and
2) it's hard to keep that amount current, based on how the data changes, or the architecture changes.
It would be interesting to see an "insurance" for these kind of things. I once thought of such a product, just after I left AWS, and for a little while I entertained the idea of launching a startup to go after that market.
- omk 6y agoInteresting. I wonder if a $1000/month insurance linked to a customer's subscription would be enough to provide a 1000x cover? Essential proving that the risk quotient is < 1/1000 subscriptions. Such an offering by a cloud provider might make a huge statement.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoThe huge problem with this is that you are giving an economic incentive to the customer to "go down" for hours or days.
- saagarjha 6y agoYeah, but unplugging your servers does not count as "my provider is down".
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoHard to prove bad behavior, though.
- nunez 6y agoDoes business insurance cover this?
- dsr_ 6y agoA normal business insurance policy covers losses to your business due to your own accidental actions, or an employee's willful illegal action, but generally does not cover a loss due to a contracted service not performing properly. So the cloud-service company might have it covered for their own losses, but not for their customers. And a company the size of Amazon or Google probably doesn't actually buy business insurance; they are larger than many insurance companies and will find it cheaper to just accept most losses in their current regulatory regime.
- chrismorgan 6y agoI have long felt that almost all SLAs are completely toothless and thus certainly not worth paying extra for. A few comments on this topic from 44 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23362073 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23362073 Now insurance, that sounds like a much more promising facet for protection. But still I wonder about the incentives: SLAs are offered by the original company and mean that they have skin in the game. (Well, they already have skin in the game as you’re a customer and if they mess things up you will look less favourably upon them as a provider, but the SLAs should in theory provide more direct financial incentive to avoid breaking things.) Insurance would be offered by by a disinterested third party¹, and thus lose that SLA incentive. ¹ Insurance in general relies upon this for scale and safety; I can’t imagine trusting any provider offering first-party insurance: they’d likely go bankrupt the first time anything went wrong.
- saagarjha 6y agoThe SLA you mentioned there was problematic because it didn't actually cover how much you were losing if the service went down. A SLA that would cover that would certainly not be useless, and likely not be toothless either, even if insurance was involved.
- chrismorgan 6y agoI wasn’t speaking about any one SLA; I was speaking about the contents of pretty much every SLA I’ve ever looked at. Seriously. Coincidentally, that very day, I happened to find what is I think the best SLA I’ve found, which went as far as refunding 5× what you paid them for the month after a certain amount of downtime, and almost added it to that comment as the first decent one I’d come across, but as I read further, the amount of downtime it took to get to any meaningful refund still seemed unreasonably long, so I ended up deciding it was still mostly toothless, though perhaps its gums were just a mite tougher than most. Negotiated SLAs may be able to take into account customer business losses (I don’t know, I’ve never seen a negotiated one), but standard SLAs never include that.
- fest 6y agoUL started that way: insurers grew tired of exploding steam boilers and asked their owners to have their boilers inspected and only insured owners who adhered to safety rules. I'd imagine insurance companies would hold the providers to some security standard.