3 ms·
Contrarian point of view -- (edit) this clever device overall takes too much capital and solves no real problem, meanwhile pressing and urgent problems needing
by mistrial9 6y ago
Contrarian point of view -- (edit) this clever device overall takes too much capital and solves no real problem, meanwhile pressing and urgent problems needing tech, remain unaddressed, year after year.
For centuries, real, physical actions in home life were improved with (mainly mechanical) devices subject to patent. The industrial revolution provides vast flows of consumer goods. Finance prospered (mainly) with loans, interest, and selling inventions like these, on large markets.
Fast forward 100+ years. Daily life is unimaginably easy, due to mass market goods for cheap, standardized living and generally, massive energy use. Markets constantly create products designed to be profitable given some game rules. Yet, there are diminishing returns. Vast, serious, ok yes urgent challenges face individuals and society, right now, and have been known for several decades.
An analogy might be the stunning success of mathematics in physics over the last 100+ years, sends multiple other soft sciences scouring math for certain curves or constants, because it worked for physics. Repeatedly, social science for example, is subject to physics-like curves and constants, searching for computable understanding, which is probably not appropriate to the endeavor.
The market is scouring product space, using formulas from long ago, to make the "killer" product. They say it here in the comments. This is to make money for people who are already very wealthy, using formulas that include massive diminishing returns (huge capital, you bet), and basically solve no real problem. Labor is over-abundant in modern times. People are living in isolation in Western Cities, and this is an isolation device. A very modest arrangement with a living person who needs work to earn money in the city, would solve the "problem" here, and requires no capital.
I suggest these talented, funded inventors look more deeply at the real ecosystem we are faced with overall, and get off of the gerbil wheel of get-rich personal consumption devices, because overall, societal survival actually does depend on tech right now.
- koheripbal 6y agoSocietal survival depends on societies accepting the use of existing technology - nuclear power.
- rockostrich 6y agoI hate seeing this in every single Reddit or HN thread about the future of energy. Nuclear power is a great option but it isn't the end all be all of energy. It's just another (probably less harmful than fossil fuels) stopgap.
- jake86868587373 6y agoAs feedback, this comment took forever to get to the point. It would really benefit readers if you just started with: ‘Contrarian point of view - we don’t need these devices in society because we have an abundance of human labour for that and there are far bigger problems in society to be solved.’ It’s best to get your conclusion out there early rather than relying on the reader to find it. You don’t really provide much of an argument for not using or developing a device like this other than there’s an abundance of human labour. What about if this device became much cheaper than human labour? To your other point about other problems to be solved, if we only ever worked on the problems pivotal to humankind (e.g. global warming) then a lot of things that are useful but not pivotal to human existence would never have been invented.
- bananamerica 6y agoIt is possible that you are doing this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy#Perfect_solution_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy#Perfect_soluti...
- SrslyJosh 6y ago> get-rich personal consumption devices I guess you don't have any disabled friends/family.
- mistrial9 6y agooddly, you are completely incorrect