7 ms·
Data centres account for about 0.3% of US emissions (less in most countries). So unless you can cut at least 200 times more co2 in other places as well, why bot
by LatteLazy 6y ago
Data centres account for about 0.3% of US emissions (less in most countries). So unless you can cut at least 200 times more co2 in other places as well, why bother?
- boomlinde 6y agoWhy bother improving anything at all if it doesn't immediately save the world in itself?
- LatteLazy 6y agoBecause other things achieve something. Me getting a new job won't save the world, but it will improve my income. This achieves nothing at all, for me or for the environment. We have a huge problem at the moment where people think they're achieving something by personally cutting their co2 emissions by a few kg per year. Global emissions continue to rise. So they're not achieving anything. Before we can achieve something, we have to get people to realise they are not already solving the issue.
- perfunctory 6y agoNobody is saying that improving data center efficiency will save the world. But saying that it achieves nothing at all is another extreme. > people think they're achieving something by personally cutting their co2 emissions by a few kg per year. If they reduce their emissions a bit and think that's enough - well, that's bad. If they realise it wasn't enough and more needs to be done - well, that's better than nothing. At least it's a step in the right direction. I agree with you that global emissions just stubbornly continue to rise. Whatever we do to cut emissions just doesn't seem to matter somehow. And it's very frustrating. Yet, I think, just leaning back and doing nothing is not a solution.
- LatteLazy 6y agoI agree that doing nothing isn't a solution. But that doesn't make this a solution either. That's sort of my wider point here. We need an actual solution, this isn't that, this might be part of that, but until we have that, it's not worth anything.
- perfunctory 6y agoI agree that we need an actual, real, global solution. But where will it come from? It's not like some benevolent aliens will write up a grand plan and hand it down to us. No. The final solution will consist of a myriad of sub solutions and measures. And improving data center efficiency will be a (albite a small one) part of it. So it's nice to have it (and other parts) at hand ready. You know, just in case the next congress gets serious about tackling the climate crisis.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThe issue I have is that we have had sub-solutions for decades. We've always lacked the overall strategy and will. More subsolutions is not useful because it won't create an overall strategy. Were in "1000 spoons when all you need is a knife" and we're rapidly searching for more spoons and celebrating spoon production. They're actually worse than useless. People mistake more options for action. And people spend more time arguing over which sub solutions to implimented while implimenting nothing.
- perfunctory 6y agoYou do have a point. We absolutely lack any meaningful action, unfortunately.
- adamsea 6y ago> We have a huge problem at the moment where people think they're achieving something by personally cutting their co2 emissions by a few kg per year. I used to think that. Now I believe that my behavior influences other people’s behavior, and that when people make these individual behavior changes they are precursors to those individuals also doing things like getting more politically involved with environmental causes, etc. Small changes preclude bigger ones when it comes to human behavior (I think?). Basically the individual actions can help shift social norms and that is important, is what I now believe.
- LatteLazy 6y agoI think influence is 100 times better than individual action. But I also think the same logic applies: if it hasn't worked for 50 years, and things have gotten much much worse, why will it suddenly succeed in the next 10?
- adamsea 6y agoSociety's view of climate change has shifted over the past 50 years; I think that individual actions contribute to shifting society's view on things.
- axitanull 6y agoOr recently: why bother wearing face mask at all if it doesn't fully prevent covid-19? Or: why should I do my part when everyone's selfish?
- sp332 6y agoEach marginal ton of CO2 is going to make things worse. It's not like there's a threshold over which things are going to be maximally bad. It could still be worse if we pollute more. It might be difficult to measure a single such cut, but a few hundred could be noticeable. https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/07/manage-your-expectations-about-the-benefits-of-emissions-cuts-study-says/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/07/manage-your-expectat...
- LatteLazy 6y agoRight now, civilisation will be over in a few generations due to climate change. If I cut my emissions to zero, and 1m other people do the same today then... civilisation will be over in a few generations. This is what no one seems to get. The change we want is not small, we don't actually care about about delaying this a year or two. It's avert disaster or don't. We cant solve this problem one tonne at a time. We either all get together and solve it. Or we don't solve it at all.
- coldpie 6y agoNo one is suggesting it be solved one ton at a time. A billion different solutions all working together is how it is solved. This is one of those billion.
- rapnie 6y agoExactly. I see the all or nothing, now or never argument being made very often. The 'all now, all together' is quite unlikely to happen so that leaves resigning to a 'never gonna happen' defeatism. Instead every little bit still counts, and we need to speed up contributing them to our efforts.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 6y agoThat's fine, but now you need another 999,999,999 solutions. Until they're here and implimented along with this one, we don't have an actual overall solution do we? Oh wait, no, emissions went up again while we've been talking and getting this ready. So we actually need one billion and three more solutions to get to the same place the original billion would have got is to. This is the reality of it situation. Sorry to be so bleak. But I think people (a) think we're making progress, and by any actual measure we are not and (b) think that piecemeal, you-do-you solutions will work, when they haven't for the last 50+ years.
- thewhitetulip 6y agoI am not a fan of such comments, they always want either a perfect solution or no solution at all. There was this guy who debated with me online about using solar panels because 'they are not efficient enough' and another one who debated planting trees. It is a step by step process. We will not magically cure up the ecology in one day in one swoosh. It'll take small efforts from various aspects.
- LatteLazy 6y agoSo far, we're making less than no progress because global net co2 emissions continue to rise. Do you agree?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI do not agree with this. Renewables and EV uptake is accelerating at an unprecedented pace, we just haven't hit the tipping point yet. We're definitely not moving fast enough, but we're still moving pretty fast on the economic proposition of renewables and electrified transportation alone.
- LatteLazy 6y agoSo do you believe that global net co2 emissions are not currently growing? Or that we are making progress despite them growing?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThe latter.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThen I'd have to ask how you measure progress? Are you referring to a moral/social sense of improving? Right now, We're not just emitting co2, we're emitting more this year than last year. And the amount more is rising as well. Any actual measure of co2E emissions shows this problem is bad, its getting worse and its getting worse faster over time.
- totetsu 6y agoWe are still in the "yes and" times