4 ms·
I have none of the knowledge and all of the curiosity about at what point is it cheaper to just commission a new one. A fire burning that long must be pretty h
by Waterluvian 6y ago
I have none of the knowledge and all of the curiosity about at what point is it cheaper to just commission a new one.
A fire burning that long must be pretty hot. Does that compromise the steel? Is the wiring and electronics basically gutted by now?
Also curious. It was being refitted. Would they have removed most of the fuel (or left it low)? Was it full of hmmvws and APCs and stuff? I guess it wouldn’t have a traditional ammunition battery wanting to explode, it’s not a battleship or anything. Jet fuel?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Yoric 6y agoI'm 99% sure they remove everything before refitting, both to avoid accidents (Jet fuel and sparks don't mix well, for instance) and to avoid theft ("I'm sure I left my Tomahawk somewhere. Has anyone seen it?")
- culturestate 6y ago> at what point is it cheaper to just commission a new one I have no idea how they perform the calculus on this, but remember that the USS Cole had a hole blown in its hull large enough that it had to be transported back to the US on top of another ship, and was still put back into service after refit.
- Kye 6y agoThey probably felt a need to make a statement with the USS Cole given the nature of the damage.
- Waterluvian 6y agoI wonder if they’ll do the same. Not as a message against fire but as a message to all the sailors that these ships are more than tools. They’re homes with names and histories and traditions. I think this is a likely answer to my question.
- mrep 6y agoGranted, this was in the 40's, but they even raised most of the sunk boats in pearl harbor and rebuilt them after the attack [0]. [0]: https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/Decoder/2012/1207/Pearl-Harbor-resurrection-the-warships-that-rose-to-fight-again https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/Decoder/2012/1207/Pea...
- tomxor 6y agoThat is so cool, each time I learn some aspect of the resourcefulness of countries involved in ww2 I always feel inspired. Random story connection at miniature scale - While traveling around Loas a few years ago, one of the places we stayed was on a river with boats available, the other guests took the few canoes available in the evening before we had a chance... my partner was quite disappointment as we were only there for one night. I found what at first looked like an unsalvagable very green old wooden one sunk about 4ft next to the pontoon, since I had nothing else to do - within about 30mins, some perseverance, creative use of levers and sheer "manliness" I managed to surface enough of it to flip it over and scoop some air into it, drag it to shore, empty it, polish the algea off the seats and put it back in the water to test it's hull. We had a great time in our old green boat, and ended up exploring more of the river's tributaries than all the other guests :) There is something very satisfying about bringing stuff back to life when you have real utility for it and then enjoying it.
- culturestate 6y agoI actually didn't know about this; I thought they were mostly scrapped. Thinking of it in the context of the war, though, it makes total sense that they'd try to refit as many intact hulls as they could to speed up procurement.
- lsllc 6y agoThat might have been more to do with metal shortages during the war than the cost to rebuild: https://www.sarahsundin.com/make-it-do-metal-shortages-during-world-war-ii/ https://www.sarahsundin.com/make-it-do-metal-shortages-durin...
- kryogen1c 6y ago> Would they have removed most of the fuel Low fuel is more dangerous than high fuel. Most Navy fuels will put out low temperature fires on contact - the ignition hazard is from the fumes. A mostly empty fuel tank full of vapors is easier to catch fire and more explosive when it does. > I have none of the knowledge and all of the curiosity about at what point is it cheaper to just commission a new one. it is almost certainly cheaper to decommission if all you consider dollar cost. however, there are concurrent concerns about fleet readiness that may outweigh some dollar differential.
- jki275 6y ago> Low fuel is more dangerous than high fuel. Most Navy fuels will put out low temperature fires on contact - the ignition hazard is from the fumes. A mostly empty fuel tank full of vapors is easier to catch fire and more explosive when it does. -- that's for mogas and such, dfm doesn't really have that problem. Most tanks are kept empty in yard periods.
- rpdillon 6y agoNavy Times says it had about a 1 million gallons on board. https://www.navytimes.com/news/your-navy/2020/07/12/amphibious-assault-ship-ablaze-in-port-san-diego/ https://www.navytimes.com/news/your-navy/2020/07/12/amphibio...
- blktiger 6y agoNot sure about the fuel, but the hold was almost certainly empty. When I was onboard one of these while it was in port in Japan the hold was empty. I think since these are typically used to transport Marines they are empty until they need to take Marines somewhere.
- zentiggr 6y agoAt the start of shipyard periods, they will have unloaded just about all embarked equipment, the planes would be based elsewhere nearby, fuel stock unloaded to minimum levels, all ammunition stores unloaded, the spaces to be worked on would be cleared in abidance with fire safety procedures. Nevertheless, there's always a risk... This is just definitely the most dramatic accident in a long time. In answer to another comment, it won't get to the point of replacing the ship unless by some crazy chance the fire continues so long as to be catastrophic. Each ship of this class costs billions. Repairs will be more effective almost too the point of actual hull compromise.
- jki275 6y agoRetired Navy here... Yes, it will probably be cheaper to build a new one at this point. Yes, steel is compromised, wiring and electronics gutted. Millions in equipment that isn't even made anymore has been destroyed. Many of the systems in the island are moved from ship to ship as new ships commission as they can't make new ones anymore. This is the worst fire disaster the Navy has had since Forrestal, with the possible exception of the Miami. We're just very fortunate nobody died. Yes, nearly all fuel is normally removed -- both DFM and JP5, all of the USMC equipment would have been removed, all of the ammunition and arms (remember, this is a mini-aircraft carrier, it absolutely does have a fuckton of ordnance onboard in normal operations) would have been removed. In this case, and I have no idea why, they had 900k gallons of DFM onboard, which is not normal for a maintenance period and suggests perhaps they were doing tank validations or something.
- ardy42 6y ago> Millions in equipment that isn't even made anymore has been destroyed. Many of the systems in the island are moved from ship to ship as new ships commission as they can't make new ones anymore. Have any examples of this? I wouldn't be surprised if it was classified, but I'm curious. You'd think they'd make sure everything is replaceable, since equipment tends to get destroyed in wars.
- jki275 6y agoNothing classified Things like the SPN-41 are definitely far out of production (those cards are literally through-hole construction with discrete components and DIPs for ICs), Possibly SPS-48/49, lots of combat systems equipment, etc. There are tons of things like that where the contracts to build them ran out decades ago. I suppose I shouldn't say totally irreplaceable, the government will contract with someone to go back and build new ones if they have to in order to outfit, but the process to do so would be so cost prohibitive it would be smarter to just create a whole new system. Imagine systems where the entire worldwide demand is less than 25 systems (one each for the CVNs and LHD/LHAs), all of them were built in the 1980s/1990s, and all of them were essentially hand built then. Nobody can profitably keep a production line open for them, even spares are built and provided with the systems at delivery. So if you need a new one, you're kind of screwed. You either have to go back and pay a huge premium and hope the original company (if it exists, and sometimes it doesn't) can replicate their decades old work and build you a new one, or you have to contract to develop a new system. Kind of a catch-22 -- both are prohibitively expensive. We had systems on my first boat in the 90s that had been built in the 60s and continually refurbished and upgraded since, no new ones had been built since the 70s and 80s. You can tell by the serial numbers.
- etrevino 6y agoI don't think it's possible to find the information on the pricing of just the ships' hull/superstructure. But from one paper I found the hull of a commercial ship is a pretty considerable expense (about a third of the total cost).[1] I can only imagine that the cost of a USN ship's hull is more expensive. Then there's this report from Rand: "Equipment costs range from 35 to 57 percent of construction costs for the ship types we analyzed, while material costs range from 11 to 17 percent."[2]. I don't know how much of that exactly is hull/superstructure, but I think we can assume that it's a considerable portion. Also, building a ship takes a ton of time. So the USN may think it's better to return this ship to the fleet than build a new one. That ties into another reason that maybe factors in here. It might be worthwhile in the sense that during war the USN will probably not have the time to build a new ship to fight. So giving its technicians experience in bringing a ship back into service might be helpful. [1] http://www.mar.ist.utl.pt/jgordo/Artigos%20Oficiais/091%202018.pdf http://www.mar.ist.utl.pt/jgordo/Artigos%20Oficiais/091%2020... [2] https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monographs/2006/RAND_MG484.pdf https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monographs/2006/R...
- ajmarsh 6y agoAbout 750MM according to Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Bonhomme_Richard_(LHD-6) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Bonhomme_Richard_(LHD-6)