7 ms·
Rule 14: Do not argue with trolls — it means they win. This has been a basic tenet of the Internet for decades - until Twitter and FB became huge. Now the reg
by theshrike79 6y ago
Rule 14: Do not argue with trolls — it means they win.
This has been a basic tenet of the Internet for decades - until Twitter and FB became huge.
Now the regular people don't know or understand this and continue to interact with trolls (retweeting, subtweeting, basically bringing attention to their idiocy). This just feeds the anger cycle and shuts down all attempts at sane discourse.
You don't tell a troll you're not arguing with them, don't block them (that's a win), you just ignore it completely. If everyone would follow this rule, the crazies would be left alone shouting into the emptiness.
- wh-uws 6y agoI think about this a lot. Twitter and FB brought a lot of people to the internet who weren't exposed to cultural things like Rule 14 that I feel went a long way to maintaining civility. They also normalized bringing your identity online. Back in the days i.e. when slashdot would have been HN everyone was anonymous. I feel like it made it easier to focus on ideas instead of the people saying them. Ah simpler times...
- snakeboy 6y agoIt's a bit of a double-edged sword, no? In many contexts, having identity tied to your online profile should make people act more like humans and less like they're role-playing their anonymous internet troll persona.
- sowellecho 6y ago>>In many contexts, having identity tied to your online profile should make people act more like humans and less like they're role-playing their anonymous internet troll persona. This is only true if everyone agrees on facts. It is perfectly reasonable for people to get shocked by the other side's views if they do not disagree on the facts. When people are in fundamental disagreement with other viewpoints, I would say their behavior is often one angry message away from the anonymous troll personas. It is a very short fuse. A good example is the idea of the "cancel culture". Do you think it is a reality? Someone like Stefan Molyneux would say yes. Someone like AoC would say no. The person who thinks cancel culture is a real thing will say things which just seem completely idiotic to the other side, and vice versa. And they are still using real names. Using real names in fact becomes a liability if there is actually a cancel culture. So, for example, I am safer making this point anonymously. If I accidentally end up offending you, at least I don't have to worry about losing my job.
- zozbot234 6y ago> In many contexts, having identity tied to your online profile should make people act more like humans That's the point, isn't it? A person can be good or bad, but when you group people together via social media, you find out just how many of them are just terrible human beings. People acting like humans is exactly what you don't want to happen.
- PedroBatista 6y agoSo.. you want people to act like robots? The psychologists and drug companies would love that.
- johnchristopher 6y agoI don't buy it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September has been around two decades before Facebook and Twitter.
- yetanta 6y agoYou may be looking back into the past with some rose color glasses. SD was not that good either. Its moderation system basically enforces first posting being the ones who got to control the conversation. So it encouraged camping so you could yell loudest. They added a 'troll' over on soylent. But that did nothing. It just gave people more ways to abuse each other. They even gave more people more mod points. Thinking that would fix things. But it still has the -1/5 problem SD has. The up/down system that hacker and reddit use has its own issues very similar to SD. Early ideas get the most attention late ones get nothing. Wisdom of the crowd sometimes works. But it also can create a negative feedback loop where bad ideas do pop to the top touted as good ones. One of the underlying issues is the use of text. Text is a terrible way of conveying conversational meaning. Which I personally think is how many people consume the internet. "oh that is a good idea" can have so many shades of meaning from "that is actually a really terrible idea lets never talk about that again" to "yes I 100 percent agree lets do that right now". In conversation depending on which word gets the inference the meaning changes. In my head I hear it one way. But you read it a different way and the next person reads it in a totally different way.
- Larrikin 6y ago4chan is a shining example of the outright failure of anonymity on the internet shines a light on the discussion. That concept just introduces people who will argue completely in bad faith, have their argument taken down eloquently by a new user not realizing what is going on, the that same troll will just post the argument again, constantly. Real names are absolutely not necessary for a good discussion but social and structural consequences are very important in removing trolls. HNs rule if allowing throwaway accounts for discussing sensitive content is a good thing, but I'd prefer some kind of linking to the main account to make it obvious that if you're making a green account you troll it will effect your main account as well.
- syshum 6y agoFacebook is a shining example of the outright failure of Real Names Policy on the internet. That concept just pushes people to extremes, and excludes moderate voices that will be canceled by all sides for having an opinion that is not exactly in alignment with either extreme Real Names polices that have been tried have also proven to do nothing to remove trolls at all, in fact the only thing that remains is shit string trolls and extremist that want to yell at each other after the shit stirring trolls rile them up It is concerning that I am seeing more and more people push for a resurgence of "Real Names" policies on the internet as a way to curb extremism and/or trolling even after it has been proven to do nothing of the sort
- randomsearch 6y agoThe problems with Twitter are not trolls in a conventional sense, so these tactics won’t work.
- pjc50 6y agoTrolling as a tactic won, because DFTT was never sufficient and banning was the only way. Once trolling was normalized by a presidential candidate, it was impossible to argue that he should just be ignored.
- ForHackernews 6y agoTrump isn't a troll, he has no sense of whimsy and he obviously cares way too much. The whole point of old-school trolling is to wind up the rubes over some trivial nonsense for your own amusement. Incidentally, PHP is a fantastic language and Haskell is hot garbage.
- Jonnax 6y agoWords change their meaning. Troll has not meant that in more than a decade.
- viridian 6y agoBut the modern meaning is basically either just "someone I disagree with", "someone I don't like", "someone acting in bad faith", or "someone in the out group". It's a word that means practically nothing now.
- nix23 6y agoIf your going really old-school 'trolling' look up Red herring...trump trows allot of them around. >Incidentally, PHP is a fantastic language and Haskell is hot garbage. That's NOT Trolling if both of them are fantastic.
- brabel 6y agoYou completely misunderstand trolling if you think a real politician using his real name would be trolling on the internet! Saying stupid things or even outrageous (in your view) things is not trolling unless it's said for the sake of provoking people who hold those views. If you actually believe your stupid points of view, you should not be called a troll, merely an idiot.
- dijksterhuis 6y agoIn case anyone is unsure of what the Rules of the Internet are: https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/30662 https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/30662 https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/rules-of-the-internet https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/rules-of-the-internet ___ As an aside, Godwin's law is why code reviews had to be locked down at one of my previous employers: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoSounds like said code reviews were getting outright toxic and vile; referencing Hitler was probably not the main issue there.
- eythian 6y agoMaybe they were just writing a lot of `AbstractHitlerBeanFactoryBuilder` classes.
- toyg 6y agoOn a more serious note, there is an argument for all computing being fundamentally authoritarian. You have one root account dictating how other users can consume resources, and from that you descend onto things like "the project owner". If this model is not tempered downstream, I can see how people can end up shouting "nazi" at each other. (still, I guess one should probably catch himself before violating Godwin's Law in a work environment...)
- pjc50 6y agoRMS was anti-root (or anti-"wheel", I can't remember) for basically this reason. There certainly is a lot to be analyzed in the power relations of control of the means of production and distribution of information, from the society wide scale to the individual device, but technologists are remarkably bad at doing this.
- 6y ago
- WalterBright 6y agoTwitter should just disable the retweet feature. I know they won't, though. Sigh.
- vorpalhex 6y agoRight, retweets are there to enhance "engagement" and "engagement" sells ads. Twitter is a platform for selling ads and nothing else - that you're allowed to converse on it is a secondary feature.
- Loughla 6y ago>Twitter is a platform for selling ads and nothing else - that you're allowed to converse on it is a secondary feature. Isn't that just every social media or discussion site? This seems like a nothing statement.
- vorpalhex 6y ago> Isn't that just every social media or discussion site? Do you see ads next to this comment? What about on IRC? Mastodon? What if I told you that even many of the youtube series you may like are available on other platforms and you can pay a subscription fee to see them without ads? There are alternative to "engagement" based networks, they exist now and you can support them and choose to use them over Twitter and Facebook.
- luckylion 6y ago> If everyone would follow this rule, the crazies would be left alone shouting into the emptiness. On the other hand, unless that's society consensus, you'll just have the crazies screaming, the media picking it up and amplifying it and the politicians acting on it. Unless we vote on everything in person (or commit to not changing policy), not publicly disagreeing with something is a problem. I've had this happen (accidentally, there wasn't any malicious intent, I believe) in a community I'm part of. Some people felt that a certain policy was unfair, so they petitioned for its removal. I (and apparently most others) hadn't bothered paying attention to the "Feature Request" forum for policies, so nobody spoke up to point out the side effects of the intended change. The change went through, we suffered the fallout. The side effects weren't "omg the community is broken now" large, otherwise the change would surely have been reverted, but they were significant enough that you could measure it. That's my main issue with the whole public debate thing. You can either tune out and fatalistically accept whatever happens, or you can tune in and try to stop what you consider to be detrimental. There's no "hey, this works, let's just keep it working, and not spend so much energy on how it could be changed" position. I usually choose fatalism these days because my energy is limited, but of course that means that those who choose to invest their energy into politics instead of contribution are in charge, and I'm not so sure they're the people we want to be in charge.
- darkwater 6y ago> Rule 14: Do not argue with trolls — it means they win. > This has been a basic tenet of the Internet for decades - until Twitter and FB became huge. This predates Internet by a long way and it is called "common sense".
- bartread 6y agoAgreed. But I think the point is it goes out the window, particularly on facebook and twitter. I.e., the "common sense" isn't that common, and the platforms enable and amplify the behaviour.
- RealStickman_ 6y agoCommon Sense does not appear to be very common then.
- watwut 6y ago> Rule 14: Do not argue with trolls — it means they win. Now of course, if you systematically do that, the version of reality that trolls are broadcasting wins. Because no other then trolls voice is to be heard. And that what happening on the internet for years, where people who were harassed and trolled were expected to shut up and leave the place. And recently, I am equally thankful to historians who do engage with what trolls are saying. Because "smart" people just used to let trolls version of it to stand. That rule made people who followed it fail and loose. So, people are not following it anymore.
- pjc50 6y agoIndeed. You can't have "the antidote to bad free speech is good free speech" and "don't feed the trolls" at the same time.
- thinkingemote 6y agoIgnoring the troll is complicity now, okay.
- watwut 6y agoSometimes yes, just like in real life. Not always through. What is complicity through, is to favoring trolls speech. Telling troll victim to shut up or to tell him that what is happening to him is because he was not sufficiently silent. Sometimes, trolling is crazies. Other times, and quite often, it is tactic to shut up opponents. And it works and used to work. People who ignored trolls are not to be heard, because trolling stopped their speech. And yet other times, what you call troll is someone espousing genuine opinion, but it is too comfortable and politically beneficial to pretend it does not exists.
- chasd00 6y agowhat does "too comfortable" mean? I should choose to suffer because of outragebait on the Internet? that's crazy.
- 6y ago
- peroporque 6y agoRule 14a: never argue on Twitter. Yelling one-liners at each other is the opposite of a thoughtful discussion.
- mc32 6y agoI can understand strangers or acquaintances to some extent but you’ll have siblings and parents and children hanging their dirty laundry out in the open ??? Like WTF... it’s worse than having a yelling match out in the driveway for neighbors to hear because eventually the neighbors forget.
- rapnie 6y agoVery nice guide on Avoiding Trolls: https://github.com/prettydiff/wisdom/blob/master/Avoiding_Trolls.md https://github.com/prettydiff/wisdom/blob/master/Avoiding_Tr...