4 ms·
> Most fundamentally, I’ve always thought that the United States had a more profound respect for human dignity. It is always surprising to me that the US has b
by sneak 6y ago
> Most fundamentally, I’ve always thought that the United States had a more profound respect for human dignity.
It is always surprising to me that the US has been able to mostly maintain this image all while operating a global network of torture prisons and, now, domestic concentration camps for both adults and children, and while imprisoning 20x+ of its ethnic minorities, per capita, compared to China (which has, by various accounts, 1M+ in labor camps).
Do people not generally know what conditions inside US prisons are like? Are the torture facilities not common knowledge?
How is this level of spin even possible?
- duxup 6y agoThe bar world wide is not set very high. As for your traditional neutral nations not that involved in the world I don't consider that a good example. History is pretty clear what happens once you venture out. I think the moment you start playing the field in changing the world the world, even if you try to promote things that are 'right' things get muddy fast.
- pm90 6y ago> The bar world wide is not set very high. Erm, actually it is set a lot higher for almost every developed nation. Yes, European countries have been involved in some atrocious crimes but post WW2, the US is the only developed nation that engages in such things. Becoming a world venturing power does not imply that those atrocities are necessary, or justifiable. Most of these things are totally avoidable. Putting immigrant kids in cages, imprisoning minorities in large numbers and persistently denying affordable healthcare to citizens is something the US can absolutely choose not to do without compromising its status as a world power.
- duxup 6y agoI think much of the west for the latter half of the 20th century was happy to have the US do these things, while they kept their hands more or less out of it and could wave their finger when they wished... without having to worry about what would happen if they tried. Take a look at those nation's actions before that and you'll get abetter feel of how things go.
- beached_whale 6y agoHollywood
- dzonga 6y agomight sound unbelievable, but as a black dude from a 3rd world country, it's mostly the liberal media, NYT, WAPO cnn etc. then put in the allure of Hollywood etc. Funny thing, before you come to america, all you see on tv is mostly clean cities, no traffic in LA, a pristine NY. but visit those cities oh damn, complete clusterfuck, and see people shooting drugs on the streets etc. man, I was mad hip hop sold me dreams about sunset blvd, LA
- duxup 6y ago>all you see on tv is mostly clean cities, no traffic in LA, a pristine NY. Because nobody wants to watch a TV show about traffic.
- FabHK 6y agoYou’re facetious, but I agree with GP’s point that the high esteem in which many foreigners hold the USA (primarily foreigners that have never been there) is based on depictions from glamorous movies and TV series.
- duxup 6y agoAnd those things are entertainment, they show what people want to watch.
- FabHK 6y agoYes. I’m not blaming the TV shows and movies for portraying the things they do rather than bleak reality, and I’m not blaming people for wanting to watch what they want to watch. I’m just arguing (purely descriptively) that quite possibly the prominent depictions in US movies and TV shows have given many people an impression of the US that is more glorious than reality; and that this discrepancy is greater regarding the US than most other countries.
- lxe 6y agoThe fact that you have the ability to openly hold a critical opinion like this without severe repercussions is a part of this "respect"
- pm90 6y agoIf the ability to post anonymous criticisms online is the only counter you have, well, then it’s not much, sorry. Harsher words are directed against those in power in almost every country over the Internet.
- sneak 6y agoI don’t agree as long as Julian Assange is sitting in prison and being tortured (all without a trial!) because he published a video of the US military committing war crimes.
- redis_mlc 6y agoThe parent comment was very sloppily written. Words have meanings, so the corrections are: > while operating a global network of torture prisons No they don't. My understanding is during the Middle East wars they requested prison space in foreign prisons, but largely they were not facilities operated by the US. What complicates this situation is that many of the detainees' countries did not want the detainees back afterwards. So it's not like the USA was unilaterally involved in what happened then or now. > now, domestic concentration camps for both adults and children Those are facilities for illegal immigrants. It could be done differently, but something is necessary for border control. I'd like to see the US find a way to not detain children, regardless of expense. > and while imprisoning 20x+ of its ethnic minorities, per capita, compared to China (which has, by various accounts, 1M+ in labor camps). A prison is not a concentration camp, and trying and jailing somebody first for a senence period is different than rounding up one ethnic group and putting them in a concentration camp forever.
- gruez 6y ago>and while imprisoning 20x+ of its ethnic minorities, per capita, compared to China (which has, by various accounts, 1M+ in labor camps). Ignoring the "and you are lynching Negroes"[1] argument you're trying to make, your argument doesn't make sense on a logical level. How can you compare a relative figure ("20x+") with an absolute one ("1M+")? At least compare apples to apples. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_Negroes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_Negroes
- sneak 6y agoIt turns out that lynching black people in the United States was (and unfortunately remains) a very legitimate problem/criticism. The legalized system of prison slavery is another. But, even those aside: Global network of CIA torture prisons. Concentration camps in Texas. Universal surveillance of all communications without judicial oversight. Extrajudicial assassination of citizens. These are real things, happening today. Do people just ignore them because they don’t fit the “land of the free” narrative?
- FabHK 6y ago> doesn't make sense on a logical level. The commenter was a) comparing two rates (incarceration rate of minorities) between countries by providing their ratio, and then furthermore b) providing an additional related piece of information, namely an absolute level in one of those countries. Perfectly sound, logically and all.
- FabHK 6y agoYour retort might be formulated too dramatically, which makes it easy to dismiss (or downvote). Having said that, yes, when I came across that sentence you quote (> Most fundamentally, I’ve always thought that the United States had a more profound respect for human dignity.) I had to chuckle as well at the (then) naïveté of the author. Apart from immigration, the incarceration and homicide rates I’d also adduce capital punishment, the issues surrounding policing and race, as well as health insurance. Still, much better than many other countries! But certainly not near the top.