7 ms·
Scientists Discovered a Gigantic Structure in a Hidden Zone of Space
- airstrike 6y agoNot an expert, but it seems to me that calling it "structure" in the headline without context is extremely clickbaity even if technically correct. Why not say "Scientists Observe a New Cosmic Structure for the First Time"?
- undersuit 6y agoThe noun structure should not be clickbaity. I assume you mean because structure without the adverb cosmic would imply some sort of extraterrestrial-built structure?
- bryanrasmussen 6y agothat implication is, I believe, the commonly understood one.
- dvtrn 6y agoWhat, "aliens" or otherwise "artificial"? Is that the 'commonly understood' implication you mean? It's okay to say it. My question is, is it “commonly understood” or is it merely a convenient and very fun implication to assume?
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI suppose artificial is the commonly understood implication when one uses the term structure, but if it is found in a hidden zone of space it also somewhat implies aliens.
- happytoexplain 6y ago"Should" not, yes - though it is here, it seems to me.
- airstrike 6y agoScientists -> ok, but would prefer to omit that Discovered -> "Observe" is better Gigantic Structure -> "Cosmic structure" is better than the subjective "gigantic", as everything cosmic is by definition gigantic and it seems to imply some sort of amazement at its size in a Hidden Zone of Space -> "Obscured" zone of space would again be better So how about "First Observation of Cosmic Structure in Obscured Zone of Space" I'm not an editor, and if I can come up with a more accurate and less sensationalized title, one can only conclude that whichever editor was behind this specific headline was deliberate in their choice of its clickbaity feel
- macintux 6y agoNot sure “observed” is accurate, since we can’t see it from here. Discovered seems better. And it is one of the largest we’ve seen, and it’s very close, so there is some amazement.
- kosievdmerwe 6y agoThis is one of the ways the media (and politicians) lie. They use words that are technically correct if you squint, but severely misleading. Given that one of the functions of a journalist is to clearly communicate, they're either incompetent or they're deliberately misleading. And it's pretty clear it's the second.
- Tagbert 6y agoThis is an article in a general newsy site without a science focus. I’m not surprised that the title is borderline click-bait.
- kosievdmerwe 6y agoYeah fair, I was a little harsh. This is clickbait, though built on the confusion of a specific scientific meaning and the commonly understood meaning.
- jollofricepeas 6y agoRespectfully, I’m not sure you understand the function of the press. When has journalism ever stuck to facts? When has the “news” been more than stories and opinion? Hint: Never Your assumptions aren’t based in fact and smack of elitism. Press has no responsibility to meet your personal idea of competency. Read: A History of News by Mitchell Stephens https://openlibrary.org/works/OL1854941W/A_history_of_news https://openlibrary.org/works/OL1854941W/A_history_of_news Read: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_journalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellow_journalism Read: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_French_journalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_French_journalism
- kosievdmerwe 6y agoGiven that the media wants to claim to be the fourth estate and a vital part of democracy, I don't think I'm wrong to hold them to a higher standard. Washington Post's slogan is "Democracy Dies in Darkness". And frankly when you or anyone starts with "Respectfully", you're typically not. Your post certainly only has a thin veneer.
- flukus 6y agoI think the bigger error is that they keep calling it a fundamental structure. It was my understanding that this structure is very much an emergent property and nothing fundamental.
- II2II 6y agoThe wording of the title feels a bit odd, but I doubt that it is intended to be clickbaity. It is a feature of what is known as the large scale structure of the universe. In that context the use of the word structure is entirely appropriate since there is no ambiguity. The wording of the title feels odd because I don't recall individual parts of the large scale structure being referred to as structures, but my memory may be hazy since I have been out of the field for well over a decade.
- seesawtron 6y agoI agree that most media aim to create such click-bait titles but I think in this particular case the word "structure" comes from the original paper [0] so there isn't much the author could do. Our language is too slow to invent new words for newly discovered elements of the universe and scientists have to draw words from the common language for it to be easily interpretable. [0] https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/ab9952 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/1538-4357/ab9952
- chadcmulligan 6y ago"structure" is the technical term cosmologists use to describe these aggregations of matter in the universe I believe https://wmap.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/bb_cosmo_struct.html https://wmap.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/bb_cosmo_struct.html
- jtms 6y agoIt’s vice - these days they are basically only one step removed from a “celebrity is actually an alien” style tabloid.
- darepublic 6y agoMy heart thought aliens, but my head knew better
- deanCommie 6y agoI am highly curious about two questions that a physicist or a cosmologist could maybe answer... 1) What do we actually know about these "structures", and fundamentally how certain are we that they have any consequence whatsoever to our understanding of the universe? Is it possible that the patterns we notice are just us being humans noticing patterns in randomly generated white noise? 2) Could there be emergent behaviours at the super-astronomical scale where just like electrons and protons and other elementary particles combine to all sorts of emergent higher order behaviour in atoms and elements, could there be similar outcomes at the multi-galaxy-cluster scale that would be impossible to observe at the human scale?
- root_axis 6y agoDoesn't really seem like 2 could ever be ruled out in theory.
- gnramires 6y agoNot a physicist, but as far as 2 goes, galaxies are all atoms interacting after all. Filaments themselves are emergent structures formed from the interaction of large amounts of mass-energy at the largest scales. Forces have different ranges (scaling behavior) thus the behavior of matter changes as you change scales. At the largest scales it is mostly purely gravitational to my knowledge (plus dark energy which is also modeled gravitationally). When you play billiards you don't expect them to gravitate toward each other! If they were on the scale of planets though, you might (it depends on how you scale their velocities). Or if you waited extremely long times, and were not under the influence of Earth's gravity you also might notice in billiards.
- centimeter 6y agoMagnetic interaction is also relevant at large scales. Strange to think that magnetism has weaker asymptotics than electricity (only being found in the form of dipoles) and yet it can form much larger structures.
- bmitc 6y ago> as far as 2 goes, galaxies are all atoms interacting after all. Although, galaxies aren't just made of things only made out of atoms. Most of the important stuff is not simply composed of atoms: black holes, stars, neutron stars, pulsars, dark matter, etc.
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoOk - I am badly lost. Are we saying we have a map of the known universe, and it has a South Pole? I think this would be a cool map to share - start putting copies up on school walls like the Peters Projection
- gattr 6y agoI guess - we have maps of galaxy distribution out to a few billion light years, like the one from the 2dF survey [1]. "Celestial North/South Poles" are just the points in the sky in the direction of the Earth's rotation axis. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2dF_Galaxy_Redshift_Survey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2dF_Galaxy_Redshift_Survey
- chmod775 6y agoThere's a few interactive 3D maps of the universe floating around. A really cool one was posted this year on HN, but I can't find it anymore. In any case, here's another one: https://in-the-sky.org/ngc3d.php https://in-the-sky.org/ngc3d.php North/South pole are on that map. Since we can observe the universe for the same distance in every direction, I guess it makes sense that we'd give the resulting sphere a north and a south pole.
- todaysAI 6y agoThe more we understand about the universe, the more it's structure resembles the brain. Galaxies, or more accurately, the black holes in the middle of galaxies resemble the neurons and these filaments and magnetic fields are the synapses.
- metafunctor 6y agoMaybe that's a tempting thought, but it's clearly, how should I put this delicately… bullshit?
- todaysAI 6y agoI knew I would get this answer if at all. Just shows that humans feel we are at the centre of the universe, whatever that universe is. Sounds like the 1500's all over again. I don't understand how one can answer like this. We can't even explain the simplest of experiments; the double-slit experiment, but here we have some HN subscriber saying bullshit to something that he/she doesn't understand, and even pressed the down-vote to further show their disgust at the insinuation that the universe may not adhere to their ill-formed, or how do I say politely, childish view of what the universe could actually be. But he/she said that 'clearly' I am wrong. Not thinking that maybe reality isn't quite what we think with the small amount of information that we have at the moment. The only physical limitation is the Planck length and everything above this is fair game. Our universe could be a solitude brain and the multiverse could be the collective of brains but damn I've been shot-down by a HN subscriber that told me it's clearly bullshit.
- mikeyjk 6y agoDouble slit / quantum eraser definitely suggests to me that we don't understand some very fundamental aspects of the universe. If I think about the scale of the universe, points in time before the universe, or why there is something rather than nothing at all, really scrambles my brain. I can see both your side and the other commenters side. I think it likely your suggestion isn't true - there is no strong evidence for it and I think therefore the default position should be 'it most likely isn't so but the door is open to convince me otherwise'. I sincerely hope that isn't our reality because we would then find ourselves in a weird recursive situation where we can never understand the total system. Gnu's not Unix.
- scoot_718 6y agoIs this the terrible secret of space?
- Cthulhu_ 6y ago? the Great Old Ones ignoring us from just outside our perception isn't a secret...
- svntid 6y agoclickbait