4 ms·
"Not trying to sound militaristic, but it used to be when a national emergency beckoned, you'd have to beat people off to keep them from volunteering. Now the v
by cafard 16y ago
"Not trying to sound militaristic, but it used to be when a national emergency beckoned, you'd have to beat people off to keep them from volunteering. Now the volunteer is an unusual animal."
Has anybody told Mr. Markham that the US has had an all-volunteer military since the 1970s, or that the biggest national emergency of all was largely met with draftees? (Also, to keep an eye out of double entendres...)
- artmageddon 16y agoNot to mention that because of the kind of news and images of war we can see these days, no one's exactly looking to jump into the fray so eagerly.
- jtbigwoo 16y agoYeah, no one mentions this anymore, but there were huge protests against the draft for World War I. And rather than being able to rely on the volunteers, the U.S. had to draft something like 10 million men for World War II.
- anamax 16y ago> there were huge protests against the draft for World War I. Wilson campaigned against the war, and then turned around and escalated. FWIW, the WWI draft protests were much less vehement than the Civil War draft protests. (Curiously, the draft protests were much worse in the NE, especially NY and NYC even more so, than the in the midwest and south.) > And rather than being able to rely on the volunteers, the U.S. had to draft something like 10 million men for World War II. Nope. WWII had a surplus of volunteers and they used the draft to manage things.
- khafra 16y ago> Also, to keep an eye out of double entendres... Back in his day, people didn't have such dirty minds. And if you believe that, I recommend listening to the 1958 John and Jackie song, "Little Girl."
- JonnieCache 16y agoOr read some shakespeare. And in early 18th century britain they didn't bother with double entendré at all, they just made dick jokes all day long. And worse. https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Tristram_Shandy https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Tristram_Shan...
- JonnieCache 16y agoThe US has a volunteer army in name only. When you give the option of service as an alternative to life imprisonment, that is not a volunteer army IMO. Also the direct marketing of service as a solution to difficult socioeconomic circumstances is highly suspect.