4 ms·
"Is anyone else ever disturbed by the attempts to "make X fun!" by inclusion of cartoon characters and other inanity?" Yes, Mr Lockhart is - "A similar proble
by jodrellblank 18y ago
"Is anyone else ever disturbed by the attempts to "make X fun!" by inclusion of cartoon characters and other inanity?"
Yes, Mr Lockhart is -
"A similar problem occurs when teachers or textbooks succumb to cutesyness. This is where, in an attempt to combat so-called 'math anxiety' (one of the panoply of diseases which are actually caused by school), math is made to seem 'friendly'. To help your students memorize formulas for the area and circumference of a circle, for example, you might invent this whole story about 'Mr. C', who drives around 'Mrs. A' and tells her how nice his 'two piesare' (C = 2πr) and how her 'pies are square' (A = πr2) or some such nonsense.
But what about the real story? The one about mankind’s struggle with the problem of measuring curves; about Eudoxus and Archimedes and the method of exhaustion; about the transcendence of pi?
Which is more interesting? measuring the rough dimensions of a circular piece of graph paper, using a formula that someone handed you without explanation (and made you memorize and practice over and over) or hearing the story of one of the most beautiful, fascinating problems, and one ofthe most brilliant and powerful ideas in human history? We’re killing people’s interest in circles for god’s sake!"
- http://www.maa.org/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf http://www.maa.org/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf
(which I originally found linked on HN or reddit, and enjoyed reading ... but then what? Where is a near layperson to find mathematical writing that walks the line between Mr C and his two pies, and the impenetrable mathworld.wolfram.com, neatly skipping the textbooks written to look comprehensive to school purchasers, rather than to be useful? ( http://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/11/lost-purposes.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/11/lost-purposes.html ))
- neilk 18y agoThat was great. Thanks. I do, however, take issue with his notion of teaching math for purely aesthetic reasons. That definitely should be part of the curriculum, but I personally feel that only a few students are really attuned to that sort of thing. Others will enjoy the mechanics of calculation, and others will love reasoning and problem-solving. Some won't like any of this, but not everyone is cut out for a life where math is a big part.