4 ms·
Journals aren't charging for the publication - either for the editing, or the reviews. They're charging huge tolls for their work as peer-review gatekeepers, a
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
Journals aren't charging for the publication - either for the editing, or the reviews.
They're charging huge tolls for their work as peer-review gatekeepers, and for the career benefits - and potential improved access to funding for departments and universities - that can result from having work published in a prestigious journal.
Essentially it's like a more complicated form of buying likes (i.e. prestige and marketable crediblity) on social media, for an older and much richer market - with a monopolistic twist.
Opening access to content and paying editors more won't necessarily help. This market won't go away until the tacit benefits become equivalent. This means breaking their ability to operate together as a cartel.
Besides - in reality they only the highest profile journals provide any benefits at all. Most journals are low-profile throw-aways with limited influence and prestige. But the publishers have contrived a situation where universities have to buy an all-or-nothing access package.
If citation prestige is opened up, the cartel will collapse almost overnight.
- Topolomancer 6y agoAuthor here; what you describe is unfortunately very much true. And I also have to admit that I am a hypocrite by playing along with this game.
- impendia 6y agoI mostly agree with what you say, but I disagree with this: > Besides - in reality they only the highest profile journals provide any benefits at all. In my discipline (mathematics) there is a large middle tier of "respectable" journals, that regularly publish good work, including work by well known people. A typical tenure dossier at a middling research department might list say, 15 papers, most of which were in this middle tier, and a couple of which were published somewhere really good. I agree that the system is a cartel and would love to see it collapse. In my opinion, whatever replaced it would need to duplicate the signaling mechanism to succeed.