3 ms·
> It's like saying "Person P had 1Mi dollars and got 10% interest last year then now Person P has 1100k dollars". But Person P didn't. The interest calculation
by tsimionescu 6y ago
> It's like saying "Person P had 1Mi dollars and got 10% interest last year then now Person P has 1100k dollars". But Person P didn't. The interest calculation is correct, but the premise is wrong.
No it is not like that. It is like saying "IF person P had 1Mi dollars and got 10% interest last year THEN now Person P would have 1100k dollars". This statement is true regardless of how much money person P has today. That is how steps 5-8 work: they are true regardless of the truth of the antecedent ('in every group of k people, everyone has the same age'). Finding 2 people in Canada of the same age would NOT prove step 5 wrong (though it would show it to be pointless, of course).
Probably a much more interesting problem would have found a less obviously wrong premise to demonstrate this with. I'd love to find a way to build a similar argument for Fermat's last theorem or some other non-trivial observation.