3 ms·
And, you can now disable PINs on Signal altogether I ignored the invitations to set a separate PIN for signal until the other day, when I opened Signal and it
by anigbrowl 6y ago
And, you can now disable PINs on Signal altogether
I ignored the invitations to set a separate PIN for signal until the other day, when I opened Signal and it threw up a modal dialog that forced me to set a PIN.
I don't see any option to disable it, but oddly there is no requirement (by default) to enter the PIN when reinstalling to the same number (eg following the purchase of a new phone.
It's not that I think Signal is bad, it's that the rollout of this feature has caused unnecessary confusion. This is true to a lesser extent with other features, like the encrypted tunnel for GIFs...was anyone asking for GIF sharing or stickers in the first place? I've been using Signal for 5-6 years have a large number of peers, and I cannot recall a single person saying 'You know what my encrypted messaging app really needs? Animated stickers.'
We keep hearing complex reasons why basic group management tools are difficult or impossible (membership lists, voting, scheduling etc.) which are wholly valid, but I resent being told I need to update and then discovering that it was some useless cosmetic 'feature' or an anti-pattern like the PINs.
- tptacek 6y agoThis would be a more biting argument if we weren't talking about features that are universally present in other messengers. It's practically the premise of Signal to replicate those messaging experiences without sacrificing privacy. It's an interesting pickle Signal finds itself in. If it remains too austere, vocal nerds tear it apart for providing inadequate UX compared to other popular messengers. If they invest in trying to reach feature parity with less secure messengers, a different set of vocal nerds tear it apart for being untrue to its roots as a specialist nerd tool. All the while, to a first approximation, no nerd is Signal's actual audience; they're trying to replace SMS, iMessage, and WhatsApp, the most popular messengers in the world. That's a general observation, not something particular to your comment.