4 ms·
The peer-reviewed article is like a sacred text. Peer review came about in a certain context and that context no longer exists. Our current peer review process
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
The peer-reviewed article is like a sacred text.
Peer review came about in a certain context and that context no longer exists. Our current peer review process is flawed.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23280372 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23280372
The fundamental defining characteristic of science, the one that Feynman explicitly identifies, is that we do not decide whether something is true or false based on authority but rather based on experience.
Science never decides that anything is "true." Science is defined by the exploration of ideas which can be falsified. They can be tested to check if they are untrue.
What we call science is our current best understanding, which can be overturned if new evidence comes to light. To claim that this is something "True" is a fundamental misunderstanding of science.
This is why religion is outside of science: You cannot prove God does not exist.
There is a huge body of mental models and philosophy developed by scientists who were Christian and trying to explain to the world why their belief in God does not contradict their role as a scientist. We use these mental models a lot, often without understanding the actual origin of the rule. We use them because they have become generally useful mental models and the origin story that some Monk or the like who was also a scientist was trying to argue "My belief in God is irrelevant. I can believe in God and also be a scientist." gets forgotten.
Science is not about what we know to be true. It is about what we cannot yet manage to prove is untrue, though we have tried. Our failure to prove it untrue -- so far -- makes it the best mental model we have for the moment.