> People that did read the article and spark conversation will get more up arrow clicks. Uninformed comments will float to the bottom most of the time on HN. D

> People that did read the article and spark conversation will get more up arrow clicks. Uninformed comments will float to the bottom most of the time on HN. Did you even read the question? ;-) "Over and over, top rated comments on submissions are by people who clearly didn't read the thing they're commenting on."