4 ms·
I think the article misrepresents Chomsky's views on language to some extent. It makes it sound as if Language is claimed to simply be some special organ in the
by tsimionescu 6y ago
I think the article misrepresents Chomsky's views on language to some extent. It makes it sound as if Language is claimed to simply be some special organ in the human brain and that's why bonobos can't have language, by decree.
In fact, no such claim is made. Chomsky's point is that, given how fast human beings acquire language, we must have some special structure in the brain that gives us this capacity, that we are born with. That doesn't exclude the possibility that other animals also possess some form of this capacity, it just excludes the possibility that Skinner's behaviorist model was right - that a being without such an 'organ' could learn language, or at least that it could do it with the speed with which humans do it.
However, Chomsky is rightly skeptical of animal language claims. One of his main discoveries from studying Universal Grammar is that (human) language is mostly a mechanism for thought, not communication. This is mostly argued from the way many concepts are encoded into language in a way that is very efficient to the one doing the encoding, but very inefficient for decoding by someone who lacks the proper context - better suited to the thinking process of the person who produced the phrase, less suited to communicating the concept to someone else.
Because of the above, vocabulary is hardly worth studying as part of language, especially when discussing concrete terms. If you truly want to claim an animal possesses something similar to human language, you need to study the way it creates phrases, and the way it can compose simple phrases into complex phrases - that is where the key power of human language lies. An animal that can recognize a million words and even basic syntax ("do A then B" != "do B then A", which is already more than most animals have been successfully taught) but that can't form novel phrases from simple phrases should not be labeled to possess the same kind of capacity that humans do.
Note that none of this is to say that possessing the capacity for language should be required to consider someone conscious or worth protecting! I absolutely believe that apes and a vast swathe of mammals (and even animals in general) posses enough consciousness that we should feel morally obligated to not torture them (I do not believe that humanely sacrificing an animal and consuming it's flesh is torture; raising a chicken in a coop where it can't move more than a few cm for its entire life is, though;;; drug testing on rats is a much more difficult moral matter).
- geokon 6y ago> we must have some special structure in the brain that gives us this capacity, that we are born with We have special faculties for things like recognizing faces. Correspondingly there are people that have some damage/abnormality with this mechanism but they are otherwise fully functional human beings. There doesn't seem to be an equivalent phenomena with language. I mean, you have things like dyslexia.. but that's something that only applies to the writing word (which is kinda bizarre if you think about it b/c writing is relatively new, evolutionary speaking). As far as I know, people that can't process language at all are deeply mentally retarded. If it was some complex hard-wired mechanism in the brain then you'd expect to see functionally intelligent people that can't process language at all - but as far as I know that doesn't happen. Or does it?
- tsimionescu 6y agoThat could add to the idea that language is primarily the tool we use for thought. If you can't have abstract thought without language (in humans), as Chomsky claims, then that would fit perfectly with an observation that people who are incapable of language are also incapable of 'higher' thought. I'm not personally sure whether this observation is accurate or not.
- simonh 6y agoI'm not generally persuaded that we think linguistically, my experience on reflection seems to be that forming ideas linguistically is 'post processing'. On the other hand the rigor of trying to express a thought or idea linguistically can greatly aid the thinking process. If they are 'technically' separate faculties, I suspect that in humans the specifics of the implementations are extremely highly coupled and interdependent.
- tsimionescu 6y agoTo me at least, anything longer than 1 'idea' must be put together in language. For example, I couldn't think of a mulți-step algorithm or a plan or even a recipe without putting it in language. Still, I think Chomsky's idea, as far as I understand it, is that there is a level of language that is not immediately accessible to us, where basically your mind constructs a concept tree that can be 1:1 mapped with the syntax tree of the phrase that it could be used to represent. The strucutre itself is the same, but the thought process works with internal concepts, while the expression in external language works with English or Japanese words. The brain would work with this tree internally, applying well-defined transformations to it, merging it with other similar trees, embedding it etc. ; this would happen both consciously, semi-consciously and unconsciously to different degrees. In the end, when a plan is formulated, it can be acted upon directly, or it can be communicated to others, by encoding it in English or Japanese or Sign Language etc. Note that I am not claiming to have studied this seriously, so this is at best a layman's understanding from watching a few lectures. Chomsky also is careful to mention that his idea of language as the mechanism primarily for thought is a fringe view in linguistics, though he strongly believes some version of it will come to be accepted as correct in the future, as the field matures.