3 ms·
> Free speech defenders don't complain about "non-marginalized" groups being hassled by a bunch of random accounts either. And nothing about "cancel culture" co
by aidenn0 6y ago
> Free speech defenders don't complain about "non-marginalized" groups being hassled by a bunch of random accounts either. And nothing about "cancel culture" complaints preclude tamping down on abuse and harassment; they're barely even related. In fact, a common criticism of those complaining about cancel culture is that they _overemphasize_ politeness and civility, while allowing bad (and "bad") ideas to be expressed (the "pro cancel culture" habit, OTOH, seems to be about sticking to the a narrow range of approved views while acting as vile as possible).
While I tend towards the side of free speech myself, I think TFA is treating Reddit shutting down certain subreddits as equivalent to marginalized groups being threatened in terms of its chilling effect on speech.
This has been a common argument of the "new left" (is there a better term?); an environment of ostensibly free speech is not actually free if some groups are made too afraid to speak by the speech of others.
Through that lens, I think the rough thrust of the article is "Free speech on the internet has failed; your choice now is whether allowable speech should be dictated by the moderators or the trolls?"
Context, therefore, matters. If someone was lynched by KKK members last week, then a peaceful KKK march can be threatening by context without any harrasing or threatening language.
I'm not totally convinced by these arguments, but I think that's the general thrust.
As an aside, the fact that the "public squares" of the internet are privately owned certainly complicate matters; the ACLU certainly wasn't going to force private businesses to hang up KKK banners.