3 ms·
What I notice about the "cancel-culture" debate is that it predominantly seems to define culture as being the sphere of the people who can be cancelled to begin
by Barrin92 6y ago
What I notice about the "cancel-culture" debate is that it predominantly seems to define culture as being the sphere of the people who can be cancelled to begin with.
When I look at American discourse from the outside, it seems like liberalism, democracy, and so on are synonymous with the ability of a few high-profile pundits or 'public intellectuals' to express themselves.
I think the root of the problem isn't cancel culture but the limitation of the political to a bunch of celebrities.
I noticed this when in the US the debate about college culture wars started. They exist here as well, but they're a curiousity. Nobody equates tenured academics or a bunch of woke college kids going for each others throat with democracy or liberalism.
In tech people often argue that decentralisation is a good tool against tyranny. This simply is what democratic discourse is supposed to be. If political discourse takes place in every home at the dinner table, in the pub, in political parties and part of ordinary every day life between ordinary people and not boosted on twitter then there cannot be cancel culture because nobody individually is relevant or public enough to be cancelled.
If however political discourse is the job of the professional commentariat and the rest of society is some sort of passive mob waiting to be activated, sure then you get cancel culture. If however politics consists of people staring at TV debates for months or years and you treat politics like a season of survivor with the citizen being reduced to the role of some consumer, then why is anyone surprised by the result.
- aidenn0 6y agoWhile I'm sure that US politics is covered a lot more in other countries than other countries' politics are covered in the US, the outsider view is always going to bias towards celebrities and large events. From the media coverage of the UK in the US, for example, 2019's political process was composed primarily of citizens throwing milkshakes at UKIP members while Parliament argued about Brexit. Similarly in the US, college culture wars are largely a curiosity except when someone old wants to point out how hopeless the next generation is, or someone young wants to point out how out-of-touch the previous generation is.
- nkiller 6y ago>When I look at American discourse from the outside, it seems like liberalism, democracy, and so on are synonymous with the ability of a few high-profile pundits or 'public intellectuals' to express themselves. I think you have the right idea. Democracy has always been a tool of the majority, perhaps a wrench to be used against the minority's head. Through cancel culture, one political force in the U.S. has decided to cut out the other side of the equation from even having a say in the matter. If the other side of the argument doesn't exist, you can go on and do whatever you want. At least they think so anyway. I don't think it's sustainable for a country to be led by a group of people who has decidedly rejected the existence of half of the people in the entire country. But ignoring them doesn't make them go away. You will have to address them eventually, and at that point, the time for talking may be over, and now you've got a civil war. That's why I don't like Trump right now. That man will never be able to unify the country. Only being able to do things for your political allies and the people who you support...that is no way to lead a country. At some point, you have to address the other side. They exist and they aren't going to go away.
- hindsightbias 6y agoThe more pundits change, the more they stay the same. For all the benefits of the internet, and perhaps a rise of alt-voices in the twittersphere, the talking heads on the tv all seem to be the same old people. It should be clear from history these people aren’t there for their accuracy but because they’re part of an established narrative and they’re “safe” for their markets. Even basic contrarians really aren’t heard from within a market anymore. An example for me would be Chomsky. In the 80’s or 90’s, you could rarely see him on the “liberal” networks, but he got cancelled long ago by them. We are “free” to see him on foreign media or RT though, but no American would bother. It is interesting to see foreign networks like the BBC or NHK covering US news - the talking heads they use aren’t really high-profile in the US so I wonder how they’re chosen.
- ardy42 6y ago> What I notice about the "cancel-culture" debate is that it predominantly seems to define culture as being the sphere of the people who can be cancelled to begin with. Yeah, and to a certain extent those people have also been "canceling" people for their views a long time, but the people they canceled didn't have a platform to complain and be heard. > I think the root of the problem isn't cancel culture but the limitation of the political to a bunch of celebrities.... > If however political discourse is the job of the professional commentariat and the rest of society is some sort of passive mob waiting to be activated, sure then you get cancel culture. I think you're probably right about the root cause, but that's going to be a really tough problem to solve. A corollary of your observation is the ability of "rest of society" to participate in productively in "political discourse" seems to have atrophied. It's going to be a difficult problem to fix, and a lot of things we take for granted (like national media that gets all the attention) will probably have to change to fix it.