4 ms·
Swiss immunologist: Covid fears misplaced
- alexnewman 6y agoYep
- liamwestray 6y agoI guess the surge in cases in the US' hottest states is a testament to this immunologist's argument that it would disappear in summer... I know that viruses find the high temperature, UV light, and low moisture content conditions of Arizona generally favorable.
- gridlockd 6y agoRead the article. Having a positive test and being infected, infectious and sick are not the same. Disappeared is a strong word, some people get a respiratory tract infection even in summer, but it is relatively rare. Speaking of Arizona, the cases have increased tenfold, but the deaths have merely doubled, even accounting for lag. The core argument is about immunity however. There must have been some degree of immunity before and there is likely a significant degree of immunity in those populations where the virus has spread, like those European countries that have been open for weeks with no big surge in cases.
- scotty79 6y ago> Disappeared is a strong word, some people get a respiratory tract infection even in summer, but it is relatively rare. Apparently availability of novel vulnerable populations trump any troubles that virus might have spreading due to warm weather.
- gridlockd 6y agoI think the data shows that this coronavirus is causing drastically less illness in the past warmer months, as opposed to the months prior. This is consistent with SARS-1, other coronaviruses, as well as Influenza. That's a different matter to the number of positive test results, which is indeed rising, but is not measuring actual illness.
- scotty79 6y agoI don't think you can make that claim globally. Looking at India or USA
- gridlockd 6y agoI think you can make the case in the US, some states like AZ or FL have cases up 10x but deaths are up only 2x, even accounting for a 2 week lag. As for India, the climate doesn't readily compare to our conception of summer/winter, and if the virus only started to pick up spread recently, we have no earlier baseline to compare to. Like I said, "disappear" is too string of a word, but the correlation is definitely there, just like with many other viruses.
- liamwestray 6y agoThe difference in deaths is from less at-risk populations getting it. It was projected to have a .1% to .3% mortality rate. It had 3-5% when it spread through older populations.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoIts a no-brainer. In Arizona, and other hot states, where the temperature outside is scorching, everyone is inside where its air-conditioned to very cool temperatures, with higher humidity.
- liamwestray 6y agoInfluenza does not spread like this in Arizona, so maybe, just maybe this isn’t comparable. And it is a no-brainer... AZ is 48th in the nation in education, and 4th in per-capita unvaccinated children in schools.
- Fjolsvith 6y agoIf you get coronavirus, and are outside getting fresh air and vitamin-D sunlight, you don't get a sniffle. If you are inside, and develop congestion from the cool air, and go to the hospital or doctor, you're going to get tested and counted. Wasn't talking about the flu. Was talking about COVID. Besides, when a state as populous as California has zero COVID deaths of people under 18, why are we worried about kid vaccinations for COVID?
- liamwestray 6y agoCoronavirus us spreading in AZ despite the outside weather that does effect the flu. If your hypothesis about “everyone being inside” was correct the flu would also spread more in summer. It doesn’t. Ergo, coronavirus does not spread like the flu, it spreads more easily. The god damned idiot who wrote this article is wrong. I work in microbial research... lots of stupid PhDs who can’t do data analysis exist. Most aren’t this stupid.
- jonny_eh 6y agoThis is very ranty and not very scientific sounding. I’ll trust Fauci over this guy.
- hatsunearu 6y agoUnfortunately, it looks like not all doctorate grads are created equal.
- CaptainZapp 6y agoNote that the Weltwoche, where the original article appeared is a right wing rag, which very heavily supported the quick reopening of the country. Including the editor in chief (who is also a vocal right wing member of parliament) arguing to lock the old people away and just get done with it. Beda Stadler, the immunologist in question, is a highly controversial figure. I, for one, would not trust my health on those guys.
- gridlockd 6y agoReductio ad hitlerum. > Beda Stadler, the immunologist in question, is a highly controversial figure. As far as I can tell, he is "controversial" in the sense that Penn Jilette would be considered "controversial": - in favor of GMO - critical of anti-vaxxers - critical of alternative medicine - thinks drugs should be legalized - thinks women aren't funny (probably borrowed that one from Christopher Hitchens) As for the science, he's about as credentialed as it gets. From a rationalist perspective, it would be unwise to stick to a position that one happens to have committed to politically when the facts don't support it anymore. If Donald Trump, by chance, had positioned himself as a lockdown advocate, people left off center would be calling him a dictator and protest it at every opportunity.
- liamwestray 6y agoEhh, I supported the China travel ban until I learned it was political posturing and didn’t actually ban China travel. Trump got some heat for it, but all travelers from inernational flights should’ve been screened.
- tomcam 6y agoDo you have any substantial facts or references to back up this opinion? I don’t see anything relevant to the content of the article.
- hatsunearu 6y agoDude seems like he sold his soul and ethics in a bundle package to the highest bidder. I started reading so I can be hopeful and I felt nothing but doom and gloom when he unironically advocated for getting rid of masks. Like, go fuck yourself man. edit: Wow, I read some of this guy's other posts (back to reason, who clearly supports that idiotic german guy). Dude is just spreading misinformation in a science-flavored package. Scary. People like this are worse than the virus itself.
- mcntsh 6y agoCan you explain why him advocating against masks proves his research wrong? Can you explain how this article proves he has sold his ethics to the highest bidder, and who's even paying for that kind of thing? I'm honestly asking.
- scotty79 6y agoWhat are those novel crucial points that this guy making? I have trouble parsing it out of demonstrably false claims and rhethoric.
- vanusa 6y agoThe coronavirus is slowly retreating. With the virus currently on a rampage in multiple countries this definitely is not a good start, even given the caveat about the emphasis being "local" and the situation "not being exactly the same globally". So: Sars-Cov-2 isn’t all that new, but merely a seasonal cold virus that mutated and disappears in summer, as all cold viruses do — which is what we’re observing globally right now. I wanted to give the author the benefit of the doubt, given their credentials. But this is just weird, manipulative spin control. All indications are that Sars-Cov-2 is definitely not "merely a seasonal cold virus", in neither its origins (confirmed to be very different from that of regular cold viruses) or its symptoms (far more complex and estimated at roughly 10x more fatal that influenza).