4 ms·
I work in the field of dyslexia and always find these simulations be interesting because they are in conflict with the so-called prevailing wisdom regarding dys
by gnicholas 6y ago
I work in the field of dyslexia and always find these simulations be interesting because they are in conflict with the so-called prevailing wisdom regarding dyslexia here in the US.
Largely due to research out of Yale, there is an entrenched belief among many dyslexia experts that dyslexia is not experienced visually, but is rather a phonological condition. However, if you ask 10 people with dyslexia whether their condition has a visual component, you will get at least 4 people (and quite likely more) who say yes.
Websites like this reinforce the understanding that dyslexia does – at least for some people — have a visual component. Fortunately, the international community seems to be less allegiant to the Yale research.
They view dyslexia as a set of conditions that can be more visual for some and more phonological for others. And there are also many practitioners (assistive technologists, occupational therapists, tutors) in the US who share this broader view of dyslexia.
But it remains baffling to me that so many of the "experts" in the US are unwilling to listen to actual people with dyslexia who state in no uncertain terms that they experience dyslexia in a visual way.
The reason this has come up as a frustration for me (as someone who works in the field but does not have dyslexia) is that my startup's technology is visual in nature. The tech I built [1] has become quite popular among people with dyslexia — despite not having been created with this audience in mind.
I always assumed that experts/advocates would be happy to have another tool that could help people with dyslexia. I never imagined that there could be such a strong orthodoxy of "dyslexia isn't visual, it's phonological" could exist. This website, and the comments in this thread, provide damning proof to the contrary.
1: http://www.beelinereader.com/education http://www.beelinereader.com/education
- avianlyric 6y agoThis is interesting, I’m Dyslexic, but wouldn’t consider my experience to have a visual component (or I don’t think of any visual component as being a notable part of my experience). However I do find tools like yours very useful, it makes reading much easier for me. It definitely helps with line transitions, which I do have slight difficulty with, but isn’t the primary cause of reading comprehension issues for me. Instead most reading comprehension issues are my brain simply ignoring or replacing words completely without me realising.
- gnicholas 6y agoGlad to hear it helps! Do you find it only helping during line transitions, or does it also help with the accidental ignoring/replacing of words?
- magicalhippo 6y agoI recall reading about a study many years ago where the dyslexic participants did significantly better at reading colored text on colored background, rather than black on white text. If true that would certainly suggest a visual component, no? As you say though, I would be surprised if the root cause was the same for every individual.
- gnicholas 6y agoColored backgrounds and colored transparencies seem to be helpful for some people. However, research in this area has been mixed, and of course it's impossible to do a double-blind test when the intervention is so clearly apparent.
- jjcon 6y ago> Largely due to research out of Yale, there is an entrenched belief among many dyslexia experts that dyslexia is not experienced visually, but is rather a phonological condition From the research I have seen - nobody is saying it isn’t experienced visually, they are stating that it isn’t a problem stemming from the visual systems - there is a huge difference.
- gnicholas 6y agoThe takeaway that has trickled down to educators is that "dyslexia is not visual, it is phonological". Any nuance in the research has been lost.
- gowld 6y agoBeeline is really cool! But I think your disagreement with Yale is a spat of semantics. (It doesn't help that Yale seems confused about what "phonology" means, as they seem to blur its modern meaning of "linguistics at the scale smaller than words" with the old meaning of "letter sounds" -- perhaps they go too far in "dumbing down" the language for the general public audience). Is it hard to track sentences across linebreaks? Sure. Is that dyslexia? It's also hard to read when you are extremely farsighted or have very low light vision. It seems clear to me that there's a visual component of reading paragraphs, and then Beeline can help with that. But that's a bit different from difficulty reading letters and words. Do you have research on how Beeline (or other visual theories) affect single-word or single-line reading? I understand your frustration, though. The education and medical establishment have trouble with complexity and overlapping phenomena and spectral disorders. We see the same thing nowadays where "autism" has lot nearly all its meaning, having grown to include anyone with any basket of symptoms, even people with easily identifiable chromosomal disorders. This happens because institutions needs single term to describe their entire educational/research program, because insurance only pays for treatment for certain blessed disorders, and because lay people need a way to communicate with other and share resources. (BTW, it's confusing that the demo control buttons are so far from the text they affect. It took me a while to realize that the site wasn't broken.)
- gnicholas 6y agoGlad you like BeeLine! There is certainly some confusion around what exactly "phonology" refers to, and some of this is because the word has different meanings in different contexts/disciplines. Thanks also for the feedback on the demo control buttons on the BeeLine website. It was closer previously but then we redesigned things and it floated up to the top. Useful to know that we've taken a step backwards in some regards...