3 ms·
It’s why the dials and knobs in your car are all slightly different, depending on what they do. This has become a real problem with newer cars where everything
by userbinator 6y ago
It’s why the dials and knobs in your car are all slightly different, depending on what they do.
This has become a real problem with newer cars where everything has been replaced by a touchscreen.
- DomenicoMazza 6y agoTouchscreens have their place but not to replace controls you can activate by feel alone and access with less distraction.
- dhsysusbsjsi 6y agoThis. Even to the point that I swear people designing cars don’t factor in 100% tactile any more. For example my Skoda has a full 360 degree knob for changing aircon vent position with no detents. There is literally no way of changing from defog to face without looking down and adjusting. My Mazda on the other hand is more mechanical which may at first seem “clunkier”, but it has stops on either end for face (fat counter clockwise) and defog (full clockwise) so you can instantly choose the most common settings. The in-between settings have large and small detents as you cycle through so I can go 50% feet, 50% defog by going hard right then one click back without looking.
- wwweston 6y agoTouchscreens are modern. (Not meant as affirmation of touchscreens especially in an auto context, meant to provoke reflection about the term "modern".)
- DomenicoMazza 6y agoModern to me is novelty + usefulness. Touchscreens are modern when they do something better than an alternative. From a design perspective they’re great for dynamic display that requires (or benefits from) input... from a business view they save money on mechanical interfaces and can be used to offer new services to make money—this works out for users about as much as it doesn’t. I guess automakers are seeking to carve out a balance to stay ahead. Mechanical interfaces might come back as a retro luxury feature!
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoOn the flipside, a lot of systems that you would touch during driving - lights, heating, radio - have been automated, so there's less of a need to fiddle with this while driving as well. I've driven a Volvo once, it has so many buttons it's kinda ridiculous: http://www.frontseatdriver.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Volvo-V40-Cross-Country-2013-Dashboard-Detail.jpg http://www.frontseatdriver.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/.... Mind you that's mainly the keypad, which I don't recall ever having used.
- blhack 6y agoIn my wife's car (a Chrysler Pacifica, which I otherwise love) not only are all the knobs for the climate, volume, and tuning knobs the same, but the knob for the transmission (which is right next to the volume knob) is only slightly different. It's awful.