4 ms·
I wish the US had seen this with equal clarity 30 years ago. Some people did. Even many politicians did. But they were shouted down as being racist and prote
by reaperducer 6y ago
I wish the US had seen this with equal clarity 30 years ago.
Some people did. Even many politicians did. But they were shouted down as being racist and protectionist, and "globalism" was the future. Anyone who didn't get on board was called old and stupid.
- obiye 6y agoEven with the facts spelled out clearly in this thread, you still get it wrong. Guess you ARE old and stupid.
- EricE 6y agoYup! How many conveniently forget this now when it's politically inconvenient.
- landryraccoon 6y agoOr, we could have just made it easier for skilled workers from other countries to immigrate to the United States. 30 years ago (or even 5 years ago) I'm sure most of them would have happily immigrated to the US for a higher standard of living and better wages, and both they and the United States would be in a stronger position. IMO if a foreign adversary spends 20+ years and tens of thousands of dollars (at a minimum) training a highly skilled worker we would be insane not to take that skilled worker for free, if they want to move and work here.
- frandroid 6y agoThe problem was not lack of skilled labour here, though it is now, but rather the high cost of that skilled labour here, then and now. You can let in a skilled worker from Czechia or Romania but the expected wage here will be much higher than that of a Chinese worker, and they will be unemployed because the American designer of the product will get it made in China.
- landryraccoon 6y agoYou're missing the point. If all of China's top skilled labor moves to the US, even if they are cheaper then any manufacturer that needs the highest quality will have no choice but to manufacture in the US. Limiting immigration of highly skilled workers is a massive national security failure. It's a huge mistake. If a Chinese or Russian top tier engineer / AI researcher / wants to immigrate to the US we should roll out the red carpet because they're a strategic asset.
- nominated1 6y agoBrings back memories of those “Born American Buy American” bumper stickers. I was only a kid but I remember them everywhere.
- cmrdporcupine 6y ago30 years ago it was the left that was criticizing globalism. Apart from a fringe wing of the Republican party [Pat Buchanan, etc.], anybody on the "right" or "center" was doggedly pro free trade until just a few years ago, and those of us on the left who protested the introduction of NAFTA, or opposed the WTO, IMF, or the G7 or (like myself) got teargassed at the Summit of the Americas weren't shouted down and called "racist" but told we were economically illiterate and just you wait, all this free market will make China democratic... In Canada the only party to consistently oppose NAFTA and the FTA was the NDP, the left wing party.
- tvmalsv 6y agoInteresting how different two people can come to two completely polar conclusions. I guess it depends on your social bubble, on either side. In my experience, the right was very opposed to NAFTA (while the left was pushing it), in favor of free trade but not at the expense of jobs and manufacturing ability in the USA, and thought all these deals with China were going to enrich a possibly future adversary. By experience, I simply mean social interaction with middle class conservatives/Republicans, not experience in politics or "the party". And, I didn't really start paying attention to what was going on until the early 90s. (edited for a paragraph break)
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI think we have a terminology problem. If you think of Clinton and his Democrats as "left" then, sure, they were/are highly pro-neo-liberal globalization. To the rest of the world outside the US, that's nowhere close to left. They're neo-liberals, not socialists.
- tvmalsv 6y agoThat's a good point, thank you.
- frandroid 6y agoIt was neither the "left" (get real) nor the "right" who were pushing for globalization, but multinational corporations. They happen to be on the political right because their goal was to reduce workers' wages and union power, but in fact they have controlled both wings of American politics, the Democrats (fiscally right-wing and socially liberal) and the Republicans (fiscally Right-Wing+ and socially conservative) for a very long time. : liberal is not considered "Left" outside of the United States