3 ms·
Magnesium had zero noticeable effect for me until I tried Magnesium Glycinate. I later tried pure Glycine without magnesium and realized that it was the Glycine
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Magnesium had zero noticeable effect for me until I tried Magnesium Glycinate. I later tried pure Glycine without magnesium and realized that it was the Glycine that helped my insomnia, not the magnesium component. There are several studies showing positive effects of Glycine on sleep induction.
Magnesium is harmless to try at low doses, but be warned that there is a substantial amount of low quality information about Magnesium on the Internet lately. Despite what you might read, it is possible to consume too much magnesium. Magnesium accumulates in the body with a very long elimination time (days or weeks) which means overdose can occur after months of supplementing at the same level. Anecdotally, Gwern recorded a subtle downward trend of cognitive test scores over time during both of his Magnesium trials.
If you choose to supplement with magnesium, keep the doses low. Don’t escalate dosing in an attempt to capture greater effects. The high doses used in studies are for proving a point on a short duration study, so long-term dosing is likely lower than clinical study dosing. Also be careful to note the difference between magnesium salt content and pure elemental magnesium content of the supplements you’re taking, because the two measurements shouldn’t be confused with each other.
- flowerlad 6y ago> Despite what you might read, it is possible to consume too much magnesium. Magnesium accumulates in the body with a very long elimination time (days or weeks) which means overdose can occur after months of supplementing at the same level. You have not supported this with links to credible sources. Too much magnesium from food does not pose a health risk in healthy individuals because the kidneys eliminate excess amounts in the urine. Source: https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/%20magnesium-HealthProfessional/ https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/%20magnesium-HealthProfess...
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Too much magnesium from food The conversation was about magnesium supplements, not food. It’s well-known that overdose from magnesium supplements is possible. The condition is called “Hypermagnesemia” and one of the primary causes is magnesium supplements. > You have not supported this with links to credible sources. If you'd like to know more about the dynamics of magnesium, scientific articles are easy to find: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4455825/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4455825/ As for supplement overdose: You should always assume that overdose is possible when taking concentrated supplements. Don't assume that you can apply the same logic to food (as in the link you provided) and isolated supplements consumed in bulk (as with the high magnesium doses discussed in this thread).
- flowerlad 6y agoIt is safe to take magnesium supplements unless you have kidney disease. If you consume excess magnesium it is simply not absorbed by the body. Here are some excerpts from the article you linked: "It is noteworthy that intestinal absorption is not directly proportional to magnesium intake but is dependent mainly on magnesium status. The lower the magnesium level, the more of this element is absorbed in the gut, thus relative magnesium absorption is high when intake is low and vice versa." "As the kidneys play a crucial role in magnesium homeostasis, in advanced chronic kidney disease, the compensatory mechanisms start to become inadequate and hypermagnesaemia may develop." "Acute and chronic oral magnesium supplementation has been described as well tolerated with a good safety profile."