3 ms·
Shaming is a very effective technique to maintain cohesion in a social group, but a lot of your examples are using the word wrongly. If I were to guess, you mig
by roenxi 6y ago
Shaming is a very effective technique to maintain cohesion in a social group, but a lot of your examples are using the word wrongly. If I were to guess, you might be confusing 'shaming' with 'talking about problems' which are not the same thing at all. Shaming is an emotional and social phenomenon, linked to concepts of guilt and shortcoming.
Google & other companies for example are incapable of feeling shame - or indeed any other emotional response. They are incapable of making decisions due to a sense of shame. Therefore shaming is not especially effective against them.
> Fashion is an industry that built its foundations on shaming.
This one in is also off target. Fashion isn't built on shame at all. Fashion is built on giving people with wealth an ability to show it and to maintain a repertoire of signals to communicate with. The fashion industry is built on aspiration. Some people might feel ashamed that they aren't very important to the world, but that isn't where the fashion industry makes its major profits.
> Isn't the video in question is an example of shaming - the police?
It is evidence of activity that looks criminal. Police feeling ashamed isn't the thing that is going to drive the response there. I don't think anyone particularly cares if the police feel ashamed or not, they want that not to happen again and are going to be more than happy to make legal/political changes to do so. Sharing that video wasn't done informatively, it was done as a call to action to do something.