7 ms·
you claimed that CAA is for religious prosecution. Ahmadiyas and Rohingyas are religious sects who are facing prosecution. ergo, they are qualified under CAA.
by thewhitetulip 6y ago
you claimed that CAA is for religious prosecution.
Ahmadiyas and Rohingyas are religious sects who are facing prosecution.
ergo, they are qualified under CAA.
but you claim otherwise using mental gymnastics.
> They are free to seek asylum if they want.
If this is the case, abolish CAA and let Afghan Hindus and Pakistani Hindus seek asylum as well. since CAA isn't the only way right?
> Indian government to recognize them as a separate religious sect that's being oppressed.
the hell? They are facing religious prosecution because of their religion (sect isn't different from religion as sect is a part of the religion)
when the self declared 'upper castes' discriminate against upper class defined 'lower class' then it is still religious discrimination because the 'lower class' are discriminated because they have a particular religious identity.
you don't have a leg to stand on.
- naruvimama 6y agoLet Pakistan handover equivalent land to India, let us not forget Ahmadiyas created the Islamic nation of Pakistan. Rohingas trace their roots to Bangladesh and there are 50+ muslim majority countries for them to migrate to, which is not the case for Hindus and Sikhs. Moreover mayanmer has unearthed mass graves of Hindus in Rohingya areas, while it isn't surprising, that isn't comforting either.
- thewhitetulip 6y agoHindus also have a lot of south Asian Hindu countries. Nepal and Cambodia comes to mind.
- naruvimama 6y agoWhat else comes to mind? Cambodia? Unless you subscribe to the view that Buddhism is an offshoot of Hinduism.
- thewhitetulip 6y agoFine, they can go to Nepal.