3 ms·
>"The difference is in the electronics that control it. What's happened in the recent past is that there's now sufficient processing bandwidth at a low price th
by rasz 6y ago
>"The difference is in the electronics that control it. What's happened in the recent past is that there's now sufficient processing bandwidth at a low price that can tolerate top of engine conditions, so you can actually put real time control on top of these motors."
is something a non EE person would say about another branch of science he is totally unfamiliar with. We had 40GB consumer Hard drives 20 years ago. 20GB per platter, 7200 RPM. Now think for a second what precision of timing you need in a hard drive versus mechanical engine. We are talking ~50 nm/bit, ~250 nm/track, ~100K TPI, >500Mbit internal transfer.
The level of precision required to control engine valves more accurately than mechanical means (cams) was achieved in consumer off the shelf ~$200 hard drive controllers around 1995.
- Animats 6y agoThat was a quote from the CEO of the company who makes the thing. Fast precision proportional valves for ordinary compressed air have been available since the 1990s. I once had to price some. Price was over $1000 each. They're now a moderate volume product from Festo and others, and precision positioning of pneumatic cylinders is available. It's still not common. Automotive valve actuation has all the same problems, plus pushing back against big forces from the combustion process and operating through the entire under the hood temperature range. A solenoid-type actuator for this needs considerable power. Schemes with pneumatic and hydraulic power to drive the valve have been used on some race cars. Plus there are little problems; neodymium magnets start to weaken around the boiling point of water, a temperature easily reached on top of an engine block. There's now a supercar using this technology.[1] It may filter down to less expensive vehicles. It's an obvious idea that turns out to be quite hard to make work. Study guide: [2] [1] https://cecas.clemson.edu/cvel/auto/systems/valve-timing.html https://cecas.clemson.edu/cvel/auto/systems/valve-timing.htm... [1] https://www.freevalve.com/ https://www.freevalve.com/
- rasz 6y agoI fully agree with everything you said about this being a big electro-mechanical challenge, but the dude pointed squarely at the controller with "processing bandwidth...real time control" quote.
- Animats 6y agoIf you approach the control problem the way a modern programmer would - read position sensor, adjust actuator current - you need some control loop running at some speed like 100KHz or higher. Probably doing floating point calculations. So you need a powerful CPU. If you didn't have that, you might have to do the valve fine position control with analog hardware controlled by the digital system. That's how daisy-wheel printers controlled the daisy position. And you might have to have hardware timers for triggering events, like SOiC systems with PWM drivers. That's what you'd probably do if you were making a million cars. If you're making 300 supercars, just throw some very fast CPU at the problem and let it do all the work. You'll never see the extra $20-$100 or so per car in the sticker price of a supercar. You can get hardware for automotive environments with that performance now. 15 years ago, you couldn't.
- rasz 6y ago>modern programmer would - read position sensor, adjust actuator current - you need some control loop running at some speed like 100KHz or higher. Probably doing floating point calculations Modern programmer would make sure to do those floating point calculations in an ISR too ;-). Cars have been fine with lookup tables and interpolation. If you can precisely control spark, you could valves as well. As for hardware requirements. Afaik control always outraced controlled business end. Lets take Honda for example, all their ECUs from 92 (P05) onward had full facility to drive individual coil on plug, but officially Honda switched away from mechanical distributor in 1999 (S2000?). You can trivially convert 92 car with a small adapter board, ECUs shipped with all the needed hardware sitting unused for 7 years.
- sunstone 6y agoI think the issue here is more about the operating temperature of the semi-conductors. It's only recently that chips running at 400 C (?) using silicon carbide or Gallium Nitride semi-conductors has been practical and cheap enough. So these electronics can be integrated right into the motor without extensive cooling. This same technology is having an even more dramatic impact on High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission lines where costs have been dropping very quickly.
- rasz 6y agoAgain, author of the quote was talking specifically about the controller part. Car ECUs use off the shelf semiconductors. ECU module is usually mounted inside the cabin under the dash.