3 ms·
Not really. Venice is sinking faster today due to seas rising, but the city has been sinking into the mud since day one. In the past buildings were regularly
by sandworm101 6y ago
Not really. Venice is sinking faster today due to seas rising, but the city has been sinking into the mud since day one. In the past buildings were regularly demolished and new ones built atop the rubble. At some point in recent history we decided to stop doing that, to lock all the buildings in place and "protect" them. This phenomena is not unique to Venice. Whether it is sea level rise in Venice, height limits in Paris, or widespread "heritage" status for anything over a few decades old, all over the world we protect buildings and architecture. This means sacrificing the needs of greater cities and the people who live in those cities.
Let's protect all the Venices of the world, but treat them as what they are: museums or theme parks, not places people actually live and work. Venice already has the boat rides and is talking about a gate price (a tourist day fee). Next will come the wrist bands. Then the mascots and cotton candy.
How many of the tourists on those giant cruise ships actually get off the boat? Do many of them that just look at Venice from their cabins? That might make Venice the world's largest public art exhibition.
- arcticbull 6y agoI'm not sure even letting the sea reclaim it would be cheaper, the environmental impact alone might well require either a costly dismantle operation or just walling it in where the waste can't get out.
- II2II 6y agoThe city that I live in faces similar issues, even though it is young by international standards, and those issues exhibit themselves in very peculiar ways. If we were talking about a building that is actively maintained and played a significant role in events, I can understand the desire to preserve it. Yet, more often than not, the buildings are decayed due to neglect and very few people actually care about the building until it is about to be torn down. Worse yet, the structure has frequently been altered to the point where it is no longer of architectural interest. So yes, this is a concern from the perspective of the greater needs of cities. Which is why I was puzzled by the opposition due to the environmental impact. On the other hand, I suspect that these attitudes stem from something other than a desire for preservation. It may sound noble to talk about the greater needs of cities, yet some mighty nasty projects have been undertaken in the name of redevelopment. For some people this brings up extreme cases of forced removal, serving the needs of special interests, or simply creating inhumane environments.
- toomanybeersies 6y agoSounds like Australia. Lots of 100 year old buildings of no cultural or architectural significance get protected status. Meanwhile the government has no issue allowing the destruction of Aboriginal heritage and archeological sites (as well as old growth native forests) to make way for roads and mines.
- mattoxic 6y agoI doubt there are "lots" of buildings over 100 years old remaining in the Melbourne CBD. Those that do remain gain significance merely because they have survived.
- toomanybeersies 6y agoIt's less the CBD, and more in the surrounding suburbs. There are old cottages scattered around that weren't good houses when they were built, and aren't any better today. The land they're on is worth a fortune, but they have heritage status so they can't be redeveloped, yet they're also not worth renovating because they're so far gone.
- arcticbull 6y ago> Sounds like Australia. Lots of 100 year old buildings of no cultural or architectural significance get protected status. You should visit San Francisco haha.
- afiori 6y agoThere is a Slate Star Codex article[1] talking about how people die in hospitals. A common trend is that families that lived close to their elderly relatives are the most ready to accept when there is nothing more to do, while families that "fly in" to visit their sick elderly relatives often refuse to give up and try to do anything to keep them alive a bit more. One interpretation is that guilt plays a factor here. In my opinion something vaguely similar happens here, in globalized times everyone is citizen of bigger and bigger places and feel progressively weaker connections to local culture. To this you can add that this local culture is under constant pressure from new external actors (I imagine that more than a few people tried to build new hotels in the middle of Venice). [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20191122042205/https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/07/17/who-by-very-slow-decay/ https://web.archive.org/web/20191122042205/https://slatestar...
- IAmEveryone 6y agoNone of what you say actually refutes the argument: yes, rebuilding Venice would obviously cost a lot. And it would cost even more in lost revenue, considering it is unlikely anything new would continue to attract them. And while it's true that few ("normal") people still live in Venice, it doesn't follow that what remains is as worthless as Disneyland. Nobody lives in the Louvre, and it's still a culturally significant place! The idea that buildings in Venice are layered, with newer ones built on top of older ones when they succumbed to the water seems to be mythological. Venice isn't going to do cotton candy. Picnicking on the streets will get you fined, and in some cases tourists have been thrown off the island for such uncultured behaviour.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> as worthless as Disneyland. Why is disneyland worthless? It employs lots of people. It makes kids happy. It is also old enough, by north american standards, that its iconic buildings could probably qualify for some sort of heritage status. >> tourists have been thrown off the island for such uncultured behaviour. Such things happen at Disneyland every day.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoCulturally vacuous commercial enterprise. The Gap t-shirt of tourist destinations.
- labster 6y agoNot really. One of the aims of Main Street USA was to preserve the ambiance of a small town Main Street, which was already disappearing even before the 1950s. If the Haunted Mansion is so culturally vacuous, why did Cory Doctorow set a book there? I doubt it was just for the whuffie. Pop culture is culture.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThat's a nice story. Sort of like how WalMart's "greeters" have their back to the entrance.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 6y agoFor what it’s worth, Venice is already mostly as you describe: very few locals live in the city proper anymore. Most commute in from outside for work.
- Troniv 6y agoAre you proposing to destroy Venice palaces and art and to build on their "rubbles"? Do you have any sense of what culture is?
- lostlogin 6y agoWhile I completely agree you cant go knocking down building there, those building are built with parts from older ones. Eg the Horses of Saint Mark-Lysippos in St Marks basilica.
- ghego1 6y ago> but treat them as what they are: museums or theme parks, not places people actually live and work I know a lot of people born and raised in Venice who still live and work there. So labelling Venice as a theme park or similar is really not adequate. Proof of that is the post Covid-19 lockdown situation. Venice without all the international tourist has proven to be a lively and nice city to live in, based on what I've been told by people from there. Also, if we were to label Venice as a museum, then we would need to label half of Italy's old town centers as such.
- pjmlp 6y agoHowever having been in Venice a couple of times, and coming from a Portuguese region where tourism is one of the main commercial activities of the city, I can relate with the theme park description, we even call ourselves Portugal's Venice! It gets pretty annoying that when you go to places in the city center where you aren't known to the business owners, everyone assumes you are a tourist.
- addicted 6y agoThis is ridiculous. You guys do realize that Venice brings in half of that in tourism dollars per year, right? And I suspect the overall impact on the Italian tourist economy of having Venice around is even higher. So even setting aside any relocation costs, just the tourist economy (and there is more to the Venetian economy) will pay for the entire project in 2 years.
- gregoriol 6y agoOne example of crazy protection I've seen recently is this piece in Paris: https://danielfeau.com/fr/archive/annonce/3495936 https://danielfeau.com/fr/archive/annonce/3495936 it's has no archtectural value, has no history, has been abandonned for 30 years, is really in bad shape, in the most central part of the city, and doesn't even have the same style as surrounding streets... but the rules are for the new buyer to restore it as it is: can't build anything new, can't change shape or size, ... I mean, sure it wouldn't be nice to have a pink/green ultra-strange new building there, but there are ways to make something nicer than what is currently there