4 ms·
> And how much money do the authors of orphan works make now? Zero dollars. Just because you know a way of making money from something, it doesn't mean you nee
by coliveira 16y ago
> And how much money do the authors of orphan works make now? Zero dollars.
Just because you know a way of making money from something, it doesn't mean you need to have that thing... For example, I know how to make money with developers that might be doing nothing important while working for Google or some other company. Should I sue them to have access to these developers?
Even if a book is making zero dollars, it doesn't mean that somebody else should be allowed to make money out of it.
- Natsu 16y ago> Even if a book is making zero dollars, it doesn't mean that somebody else should be allowed to make money out of it. They're note making money from the book, but from making the book available. In other words, they're actually doing work on it while the original author apparently just doesn't care any more. If the author treats their own work like garbage and abandons it, I see no reason why they should be able to complain when someone recycles it into something useful and makes a profit.
- coliveira 16y agoAbandoning a book doesn't mean it is treated as garbage. You may have made the conscious decision of not pursuing the marketing of a book for any number of reasons. That is just part of your rights as an author.
- Natsu 16y ago> Abandoning a book doesn't mean it is treated as garbage. Can you name any other object that one might abandon without treating it as garbage? An abandoned house may be claimed by squatters. Abandoned goods are recycled or trashed. Abandoned cars are sold or junked. Why should books be different? Why should we not conclude that they have abandoned their rights? Why should we respect it when, after someone does work to turn their words into something valuable, they show up to assert rights? I honestly don't see how this is different from someone wanting a cut of the money made from recycling garbage they had no intention of recycling. If it was art, if they truly loved it, they would never be so crass as to abandon it until there was money to be had. If their art was like their children, orphan works would be just that. Their author abandoned them on a street corner somewhere in a bad part of town and didn't care one bit about them until they heard they were a success, after which time they returned to beg money off them. On the other hand, I suppose that the alternative, that is having their works die of obscurity, is a fitting punishment for authors like that. It's their work I feel sorry for.