3 ms·
> (open (source code model)) ≠ (open source) But that's my point. It already had a different meaning. And I don't think your parsing stands up to what the reco
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> (open (source code model)) ≠ (open source)
But that's my point. It already had a different meaning. And I don't think your parsing stands up to what the record says. People who were in the community at the time will tell you for example:
> I joined Caldera in November of 1995, and we certainly used "open source" broadly at that time.
So why didn't they pick something that nobody was using at all? Something they could trademark?
> Insanely dishonest way to characterize this.
Can you explain why you think that? My understanding, from their own documents, is that 'there is virtually no chance that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office would register the mark "open source"; the mark is too descriptive.'
'Open source' is a simple descriptive phrase - it's not something the OSI own, or coined, or have any right to lecture people on.
- cxr 6y ago> 'Open source' is a simple descriptive phrase - it's not something the OSI own, or coined, or have any right to lecture people on. You're sort of pulling back here—defending it in a different context than the way it was used in the place you first wrote it. Do you want to take this private? I'll email you. I've been in enough HN flamewars over the last 24 hours, and these types of threads where a few people dominate aren't good and might as well be private, anyway.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI don't believe I am pulling back. My claims are: * 'open source' was an existing industry term before 1998, with a broadly similar meaning - not exactly the same and that's kind of the point - why pick an existing term and try to give it a new meaning and then claim you invented it? * 'open source' is a plainly descriptive term, so much so that the even the USPTO told them this and that them trying to trademark it was a nonsense - it's like they tried to claim they invented 'sliced bread' and then wanted to trademark it - it's just an adjective and a noun With both of these things, I think it's really silly of them to try to tell people that things aren't open source because they don't meet their own pet definition (and they do that - they have come into HN threads and told people off). You can email me if you want! All my details are in my profile. But it's not my job to convince anyone of anything. I just know why I wouldn't let the OSI lecture me, and I'd recommend other people check the history as well.