4 ms·
I am working on my HAM General-class license. I have young and non-engineer friends who are into it. It is mostly interesting to them because they have never do
by jvanderbot 6y ago
I am working on my HAM General-class license. I have young and non-engineer friends who are into it. It is mostly interesting to them because they have never done something highly technical, and here is a relatively approachable technical hobby.
However, I'm decreasingly enthused about HAM. I got my license so I could interact with devices that I wanted to build. However, there are almost no use cases where HAM helps. I cannot build something cheaper, or make it more effective than a commercially available product. It's only at the extreme, un-useful cases that HAM becomes a thing. (Want to bounce signals off the moon?)
What I'd like to see from HAM:
- More, different competitions. Long-term monitoring, stealthy side-channel transmissions, digital and analog networking competitions (like hackathons: Get a signal from A to B with minimal loss / delay using teams in disparate areas of the country --- internet OK), recovery games (set up a network serving x users with max datarate or voice capacity using this equipment), or encoding / decoding games, and so on.
- More support from local governments and infrastructure. I want to know where to sign up to be useful if telecommunications suffers a hiccup. If that is not useful, I want to know and be told how to be useful (esp studying different technology). Some certifications beyond HAM, and specializing in different niche areas would be nice.
- More training on HAM-adjacent technologies. To be useful / innovative requires knowing the telecommunications space, and sticking to SSB voice + FT8 for DXs is great, but not helpful when trying to understand telecommunications and make an impact on the world. God forbid a disaster did happen and the HAMs showed up with their 10m antennas and were useful for 30 minutes until the Verizon tech arrived. It'd be more useful if they could bridge 3G / UHF by setting up an adhoc repeater network to actually extend the range of whatever equipment didn't die in the zombie apocalypse.
For example:
In the IoT area, I thought for sure HAMs would be front-and-center with new mesh networking technologies, WAN, etc. But no, we got another AWS product with minimal device-device communication and called it a day.
- sitzkrieg 6y agoits ham
- FlyMoreRockets 6y ago> I cannot build something cheaper, or make it more effective than a commercially available product. Not sure what you are looking to do, but there are plenty of inexpensive radio designs. Consider the Pixie or the SMT version, the Knight SMiTe, either can be built very cheaply. Onr could also put an amplifier on inexpensive IMS chips for really inexpensive radio projects. A Raspberry Pi Zero can be bitbanged into a transciever using PWM and SDR and can operate pretty much any mode. It's a very noisy, low power output signal and will need filtering and amplification. Still better than a spark gap transmitter, the ultimate low cost radio. For cheap recievers, look into foxhole radio designs.
- entropea 6y agoI made it across the pond to UK from NY on WSPR 20 meter amateur band using the ~10dBm output of a Raspberry Pi on its IO pins. It's quite capable. That was ~7 years ago when the atmosphere/sun was a bit more ham friendly however.
- FlyMoreRockets 6y agoYou should see what the QRSS guys are doing down in the noise floor.
- entropea 6y agoSeattle/Puget Sound area has Hamwan: https://hamwan.org/ https://hamwan.org/