4 ms·
"Coming down on the other side of the argument" is to acknowledge that until someone has provided a definition of free will, there is no argument to come down o
by vidarh 6y ago
"Coming down on the other side of the argument" is to acknowledge that until someone has provided a definition of free will, there is no argument to come down on.
Talking about free will without first defining it is as meaningless as just waving your arms in the air.
That is why "knowing a truth" is not relevant to this question yet. Without even a hypothesis from "the other side" to address, whether or not we can "know a truth" makes no difference.
- 3pt14159 6y agoIn my original comment I defined free will from my perspective. > For me, the definition of free will is action outside of the constraint of fate. Either every action of an individual is predetermined or it isn't. I'm not talking about the causal mechanisms of non-predetermined action (i.e., I'm not saying quantum probability / wave form collapse means someone has free will) I'm simply giving a definition that I think suffices for me. Though even if this definition seems nonsensical to you, I still wouldn't budge from my core argument because it's impossible to resolve any philosophical debate without first resolving epistemological gaps.