7 ms·
Why not use a HEPA filter? Surely, if it can filter heavy isotopes, coronavirus won’t fit through. Coronavirus doesn’t last more than a few days without a hos
by hedora 6y ago
Why not use a HEPA filter? Surely, if it can filter heavy isotopes, coronavirus won’t fit through. Coronavirus doesn’t last more than a few days without a host, so the HEPA filter will eventually “kill” 100% of the virus as well.
Also, ~8-18% of the population (mostly women) is allergic to nickel due to A combination of genetic predisposition prolonged contact with nickel-coated jewelry. Presumably this filter dumps trace amounts of nickel dust into the air. What could go wrong?
- owyn 6y agowow, interesting. I'm male but recently discovered I'm allergic to nickel after 30 years of playing guitar (electric guitar strings are usually nickel composite materials) but I didn't realize it was that common. I kinda self diagnosed it but I'm almost happy it's a common thing.
- dehrmann 6y agoYou should look into stainless steel frets and either non-nickel or coated strings.
- rmellow 6y agoWhat are the symptoms of that allergy?
- chooseaname 6y agoAppears to be the usual[0]: rash, redness, itching, etc. [0] Not minimizing this, it’s just that our bodies tend to react to allergens in certain ways.
- tru3_power 6y agoWhy does prolonged contact with nickel trigger this? I thought this was basically the purpose of allergy shots (expose you to the allergen over a period of time)
- LegitShady 6y agoYou can become hypersensitive (read: allergic) to a lot of things, including nickel. It won't happen to everyone but its more common in women that you'd think, perhaps related to jewelry.
- yomly 6y agoI worked in a wet lab and we were warned around the dangers of sensitization to bench-top solvents and reagents. This source might explain it (didn't really read it much) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK234810/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK234810/ Edit: Allegedly people can get sensitized to pesticides on fruits and then exhibit allergic reactions to "fruit xyz" (without knowing it was the chemicals on/leached into the fruit)
- reaperducer 6y agoWhy not use a HEPA filter? Right now nobody is sure if that will work. Maybe: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/can-hepa-air-purifiers-capture-coronavirus/ https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/can-hepa-air-purifie... This is envisioned, at the outset, to be installed in the air handling systems of places like hospitals and airports. I don't know much about HVAC, so I don't know if this was made because HEPA doesn't scale to hospital/hotel/airport size or there's some other reason. Presumably this filter dumps trace amounts of nickel dust into the air. Why is that a logical assumption? Do HEPA filters dump trace amount of fiber dust into the air? Do any other types of filters decompose themselves into the air in noxious quantities?
- closeparen 6y agoHEPA filters are good enough for the exhaust from BSL4 labs. They work. But they only work on the air that passes through them, as a barrier between separate environments. Just placing one somewhere in the room probably won’t help much.
- jaggederest 6y agoYou'd be surprised how effective "just putting one in the room" is. You can build a fairly effective cleanroom that way, and cleanrooms are a lot "cleaner" than is required for effectively reducing the viral load for things like COVID19
- nl 6y agoIndeed, and many (most?) domestic air filters include HEPA filters. I have a Phillips one[1] and it does. [1] https://www.philips.com.au/c-p/AC1215_70/series-1000-air-purifier/support https://www.philips.com.au/c-p/AC1215_70/series-1000-air-pur...
- im3w1l 6y agoWouldn't that be defeated if you talk with one of the infected? Like you would be in a huge hotspot compared to the room average.
- numpad0 6y agoHealth risks aside, supposedly filter like this would last longer? HEPA filters need frequent replacement.
- madaxe_again 6y agoHEPA wouldn’t kill it, just hold it. On the other hand, a silane quat impregnated HEPA filter would likely kill everything that passed through it, and afaik has no substantial toxicity issues.
- watertom 6y agoUV light in conjunction with a Hepa filter would be very effective.
- mschuster91 6y agoHEPA filters are made out of fiberglass, which is vulnerable to UV degradation.
- rightbyte 6y agoYou don't have to aim the light at the filter.
- LMYahooTFY 6y agoI interpreted the quotation marks as implying that it's functionally killing the virus unless you somehow blow it off the filter.
- cableshaft 6y agoWell it just needs to hold it until it's inactive, right? The virus doesn't seem to stay active on surfaces more than about 3 days at room temperature, so it just needs to hold it for that long. That's something I never really got about mask reuse either. People kept saying these masks aren't reusable unless they use UV light treatment or something, and it just seemed like if it's considered safe to touch mail after letting it sit in the garage for a few days after getting it, then shouldn't you just have to let masks sit for a few days for them to be usable again (hell, wait two weeks, even). I'm sure there's good reasons for it, just haven't seen it. I imagine some masks are considered one time use because they degrade enough after that use that they might not protect as well, but then why are people trying so hard to find methods to make them reusable that seem to mainly just involve disinfecting them?
- sdoering 6y agoHEPA is efficient, but expensive to maintain. I stumbled upon this interesting sounding study [1] from 2013, but realized that thee Corona Virus is between 50 - 200 nm and the effective filter range is between 200 - 600 nm. [1]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23263945/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23263945/
- ekianjo 6y agoCombine HEPA with UV light (at least the type that is the most effective at destroying the coronavirus) and as long as it can hold the virus long enough exposed to that range, it's probably good enough. Question is, would the UV light somewhat damage the HEPA filter over time?
- tzs 6y ago> Surely, if it can filter heavy isotopes, coronavirus won’t fit through. Surprisingly, that reasoning doesn't necessarily actually work. It turns out that there are actually several different mechanisms by which a filter can stop particles. Big particles, for example, might not fit between the gaps in the filter--think fish in a net. This is called sieving. Particles that are too small for sieving but are heavier than the surrounding flow keep moving in a straight line when the flow goes around the filter fibers. They collide with the fibers and get stuck. This is called inertial impaction. The smallest particles that the filter can handle are not held in place by the fluid they are flowing in and so move around a lot by diffusion. This diffusion can lead them to hitting the fibers and getting stuck. Particles too big for diffusion but too small for inertial impaction can follow the flow around fibers, but in doing so they can still hit the fiber and get stuck. This is called interception. There are also electrostatic effects with some filter materials that can ensnare some kinds of particles. When you put this all together, the result is that filters do not work the way we would intuitively expect, where there is some particular size and everything above that is stopped and everything below that makes it through. That would only be true if sieving was the only mechanism in play. The curves of efficiency vs. particle size for all of the non-electrostatic mechanisms are S curves. As size goes up, sieving, inertial impact, and interception all go up, but at different rates. Sieving's curve rising section is almost vertical. Inertial impact's is fairly rapid but nowhere near as rapid as sieving's. Interception's is much more relaxed. Diffusion is also an S curve, but it goes the other way, being high for small particles and dropping for large particles. When you add them all up you end up with a curve that is high and flat for small particles, then dips down around some particular size, and then rises back up to high efficiency. There's some nice illustrations and graphs here [1]. This is why 0.3 microns is used when rating HEPA filters. It's around the size that is hardest for them to handle. [1] http://donaldsonaerospace-defense.com/library/files/documents/pdfs/042665.pdf http://donaldsonaerospace-defense.com/library/files/document...
- airstrike 6y agoVery insightful, thanks for sharing. You win HN today
- ykevinator 6y ago
- perf1 6y agoIn the Article they talk about use in air conditioners. Most ACs don't seam to be able to handle the resistance that HEPA filters would add.
- sizzle 6y agoThis 100%, I froze my HVAC coil and then had to replace it after it leaked freon from an overly restrictive 'allergen + virus' pleated air filter.
- sizzle 6y agoHEPA + integrated UV light would eradicate the trapped viruses?