3 ms·
Threats aren’t free speech, however veiled. If the speaker is intending to say “I hope this person gets fired”, that’s free speech. If the meaning is “If you co
by throwaway894345 6y ago
Threats aren’t free speech, however veiled. If the speaker is intending to say “I hope this person gets fired”, that’s free speech. If the meaning is “If you continue to employ this person, I’ll take my business elsewhere”, that’s a threat. But both make you an awful person, so steer clear and you’ll be fine.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Threats aren’t free speech First, we were discussing speech not some limited subcategory speech. Second, threats of unlawful violence are not free speech. Threats not to engage in economic transactions that one is under no obligation to engage in in the first place absolutely are free speech.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Those people are not speaking - they are doxxing and actively harrassing employers in order to get the wrongthinkers fired. This is not “speech”, this is harassment and coercion. > Second, threats of unlawful violence are not free speech. Threats not to engage in economic transactions that one is under no obligation to engage in in the first place absolutely are free speech. Threats are never free speech. The law might not prohibit it or it might simply not prosecute it, but it’s never free speech. It’s the same thing as telling someone she must sleep with you if you are to do business with her—it’s quid pro quo harassment, it’s morally repugnant, and it’s most definitely not free speech.
- iron0013 6y ago“Free speech absolutists” who claim that threats to boycott shouldn’t be protected speech. I don’t think I’ve ever observed such pure distilled doublethink in my life.
- throwaway894345 6y agoIf you have trouble understanding something, I encourage you to say “I don’t know about this topic, could you explain it to me?” instead of erecting a straw man. The latter exposes your bad faith participation too easily. We’re not talking about the legal criteria for free speech; we’re talking about the philosophical ideal. Consequently, we’re not talking about what speech should be protected and which should not, we’re distinguishing between the intent to express an idea and the intent to harm others. If you’re boycotting a company to pressure them into firing someone, you aren’t engaging in speech, you’re engaging in coercion and quid pro quo harassment.
- iron0013 6y agoIf we’re talking about a philosophical ideal, then you should have no problem understanding that calling for a boycott is speech, just as much as trans-rights denialism and racial “science” advocacy are speech. I’m shocked that you would engage in call-out culture by accusing me of arguing in bad faith and constructing straw men. HN is not the place for engaging in cancellation like that. If you are incapable of formulating a reasoned argument, please consider refraining from posting.
- throwaway894345 6y agoCan you not troll here, please?
- iron0013 6y agoI’m not, but you are, actually.
- dang 6y agoPlease stop posting like this to HN, please don't do tit-for-tat spats, and please don't use the site for ideological battle. This site is for curious conversation. These things are not that, and in fact are destructive of it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html