2 ms·
> If you attend a school where students historically perform much better on coursework than on the exam, your predicted score on the exam will be lower. On the
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
> If you attend a school where students historically perform much better on coursework than on the exam, your predicted score on the exam will be lower. On the other hand, if your school tends to perform better on the exam than in coursework, then your predicted score on the exam will be higher.
This is terrifying. It works for the average student, but distorts the performance for any student who isn't typical or better than their school.
It seems that it would be better to just ignore the testing component of the IB score this year when judging students. Instead they modeled what the students would have gotten on the test, and then judged them based on their modeled performance.
- chongli 6y agodistorts the performance for any student who isn't typical or better than their school. It distorts the performance of a student who underperforms in coursework relative to their peers but overperforms on exams, at a school where students overperform on coursework and underperform on exams. In other words, it punishes the student who does unusually poor on coursework that is already much easier, on average, than typical coursework from other schools. How likely are such students to succeed at a competitive university? Not very likely at all, I would think.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI don’t agree. It also punishes students with good coursework and who would have performed well on the test, but happen to be in schools which historically perform poorly on IB tests.
- chongli 6y agoIf the student outperforms their peers on coursework, then they won't be punished, they will have an estimated score higher than their peers.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoyes, they would be higher than their peers at their school, but then penalized because the cohort before them performed poorly on the IB test. For the students who would have gone on to test well on the IB test, this is clearly a disadvantage. E.g. : 1) You are in the 10th percentile of your class. 2) Students from your school in the 10th percentile scored in the 20th percentile on the IB test last year 3) You are assigned a 20th percentile on the IB test you can not take. This sucks if you would have done better than the 20th percentile on the IB test. Why model an IB test score at all? just apply a weighing to the coursework grades if you want to standardize outcomes between schools. it would be more straight-forwarded.
- chongli 6y agoThey modeled the scores because they couldn’t hold the exams this year due to the virus. As for your description, that’s a gross oversimplification. What they’ve actually done is predicted people’s test scores based on their performance in coursework relative to their peers. A person in the 10th percentile in coursework is already worse than 90% of their peers and is unlikely to go to university no matter what school they attend. On the other hand, a student in the 90th percentile of a low performing school is going to be fine. Their predicted score is going to be well above their peers.
- s1artibartfast 6y ago> They modeled the scores because they couldn’t hold the exams this year due to the virus. I said why make up a test score instead of just using weighted coursework. > As for your description, that’s a gross oversimplification. What they’ve actually done is predicted people’s test scores based on their performance in coursework relative to their peers. This is exactly what I described. taking someone's performance percentile in their school and predicting what they would score on the IB test. This appears to be exactly what they are doing >A person in the 10th percentile in coursework is already worse than 90% of their peers and is unlikely to go to university no matter what school they attend Sorry I was not more clear, I meant top 10th percentile. >On the other hand, a student in the 90th percentile of a low performing school is going to be fine. Their predicted score is going to be well above their peers. No, a student in the 90th (top 10th) percentile of coursework at a low performing school is the ones who are harmed. They will be assigned a higher IB test score than most of their school, but lower than the 90th (top 10th) percentile student in a school with a better track record on the IB test.