3 ms·
The point isn't bike riding. Bike riding is an example of a class of problems, and your solution begs the question. The point is that humans and computers oper
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
The point isn't bike riding. Bike riding is an example of a class of problems, and your solution begs the question.
The point is that humans and computers operate differently. The human approach is based on adaptive experiential heuristics.
The computer approach is based on explicit formalism. (Even in neural networks, there's still a formal model. It's just made of weightings instead of logic paths.)
The epistemology of these approaches is completely different. The problem isn't getting a computer to ride a bike, it's getting a computer to learn to ride a bike how a human learns.
Why would anyone do this? Because adaptive experiential heuristics are far more flexible and generalisable than explicit formalisms. And - it suggests here - you can't have real AGI without them.
So the problem then becomes unpicking what "adaptive" and "experiential" really mean. Both rely on huge accumulations of tacit knowledge and tacit motivations.
If this isn't obvious, consider that a human child will learn how to ride a bike and then go and have a lot of fun with it. An ideal bike-riding computer doesn't even have a concept of fun.
The human experience of fun is a complex system of experimentation, exploration, reward, and challenge, combined with physical, emotional, and mental correlates.
This matters because play in childhood helps develop the heuristics that adults use for problem solving, and for personal motivation and satisfaction.
Even more simply, the problem is the difference between building a workable but dumb bike riding machine and building a machine that will improvise bike riding as a goal for itself, will "enjoy" the experience, and will generalise from that to mastery of other domains.
- Strilanc 6y ago> The problem isn't getting a computer to ride a bike, it's getting a computer to learn to ride a bike how a human learns. This is just a more sophisticated way of assuming that there's something human-intrinsic about bike riding. Human-like is not the only way to approach doing or learning. Whatever works, works.
- neatze 6y agoI could not agree more there is no evidence of any kind that there is some process that is human-intrinsic from perspective of neuroscience and computer science. Furthermore learning is just subset of intelligence, it seems to me most arguments are about concept of intelligence where such concept has different meaning for each participant.
- codr7 6y agoBut humans learn by themselves, from observing the world around them and drawing conclusions. Which is a major advantage and a core problem in strong AI. The only reason it works is that a lot of humans put a lot of effort into more or less figuring out exactly how to ride a bike. It doesn't generalize at all, teaching the same robot to ride a skateboard would mean doing it all over again.
- phonypc 6y ago>It doesn't generalize at all, teaching the same robot to ride a skateboard would mean doing it all over again. This doesn't sound right, but I'm just a curious layman when it comes to AI. I'm thinking AlphaGo vs. AlphaZero. Hypothetically couldn't the same relation exist between an AlphaBike and AlphaRide?
- webmaven 6y agoYes, and not just hypothetically; more generally, transfer learning is definitely a thing, and has been shown to reduce training requirements for unrelated tasks.
- glenstein 6y ago>Human-like is not the only way to approach doing or learning. I would also say that we shouldn't agree that there's an irreducibly human-like way to do things that only belongs to humans. The things we think 'belong' to humans, such as our intrinsic bike-riding ability, may well turn out to be not intrinsic at all, and able to be modeled in all salient ways by a machine. I think if we allow that distinction to be made, and proceed to argue that machines can learn in different ways, it allows a very strange human-essentiallism to go unchallenged.