14 ms·
> It [the woke revolution] spends most of its time constructing an impenetrable vocabulary of oppression and seething at the lumpen proles who either don’t get
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> It [the woke revolution] spends most of its time constructing an impenetrable vocabulary of oppression and seething at the lumpen proles who either don’t get it or don’t like it.
Man, does this resonate. The woke message is just uninspiring and the word play and circular reasoning are just tedious. I've never met a philosophy that depended so strongly on appropriating existing, morally-weighty words.
- watwut 6y agoTaibibi is good at resonating when you are predisposed to agree with him. Mostly because he is good at finding funny sounding insulting but still right below line sentence. He is good at emotional level, but less good with actual rational arguing.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Taibibi is good at resonating when you are predisposed to agree with him. That's what "resonates" means. I agree though that he's putting words to collective frustrations and not arguing in a persuasive form. I wish he did more of the latter, but nevertheless, this excerpt resonated for me.
- calmlynarczyk 6y agoThe logical fallacies with many modern examples of "cancelling" have already been pointed out far and wide. Not every bit of writing needs to be a statistical analysis (and considering the value of quantitative data is overrated, I'm inclined to agree that a well-written passioned analysis is just as welcome). Also, lol at the very same circular reasoning the above mentioned whereby agreeing with his ideas is wrong because the people his ideas attract are already wrong.
- watwut 6y agoFunny thing, I did not said whether he is wrong or right. I said what literally all his articles are, regardless of whether he is wrong or right. The only one that I think he really really should not write was one about civility and discourse. And I am not asking for statistical analysis either. All I am saying is he resonates with those who agree with him, because his whole thing is insulting common ennemy while being funny.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> All I am saying is he resonates with those who agree with him, because his whole thing is insulting common ennemy while being funny. I think this is a fair point. I’ve noticed this myself as someone who agrees with him. He’s clearly a talented writer; I wish he would wed that talent with reasoned critique instead of being a mere cathartic voice. The primacy of catharsis is a distinguishing feature of cancel culture and moderates getting their own cathartic voices risks creating a moderate counter-mob. Moderates’ strength is reason and tolerance and we should stick with those virtues even if it demands emotional strength and moral courage.
- happytoexplain 6y agoAgreed - it's really hard to give somebody the benefit of the doubt when they sound like they enjoy making fun of people with differing viewpoints.
- happytoexplain 6y agoWhat is the difference in these cases you're referring to between "appropriating existing words" and "using words"?