3 ms·
How long until we can deploy fleets of microdrones capable of killing pests with computer vision and lasers?
by tootie 6y ago
How long until we can deploy fleets of microdrones capable of killing pests with computer vision and lasers?
- dkarp 6y agoDon’t forget those pests to us are food to other organisms.
- tootie 6y agoBut we're already killing them in vast quantities using chemical biocides. Micro Laser Drones (tm) are only killing pests that are already doomed. They just don't seep into the water table or cause cancer.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 6y ago"“Unprecedented” locust invasion threatens crops in East Africa " https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22205251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22205251 (not yet)
- IAmEveryone 6y agoWe've kinda been doing that for a while, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biopesticide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biopesticide More mechanical contraptions also have a long history, and do actually include lasers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_scarer#Lasers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_scarer#Lasers But most pests are rather microscopic. I doubt we will ever construct silicon/metal hardware better able to operate at the level of, say, spores than the biological systems that are natural to that environment.
- totetsu 6y agodrones are used to disperse corn moth preditor larve in germany, and cv is being tested on mobile platforms that can target spray or dig plants.
- hosh 6y agoOr, I can plant things that repel specific pests, plant things that attract the natural predators of that pest, or plant sunflowers and tobacco as sacrificial plants. I can let the chickens go after the pests. I can recognize that sometimes, the pests are a solution to a different problem, and adjust things accordingly. All of those solutions are more resilient than microdrones, computer vision, and laser. These high tech solutions require a long global supply chain. They don't make them as robust as as they used to. Further, having multiple, redundant pest management systems means that when one of them fails, they won't all fail.
- tootie 6y agoIf that were true farmers would already be doing it.
- ellis-bell 6y agothe whole efficient markets argument requires pressure in both directions. no one is short selling farmers. just like how if a house is overpriced and real estate investors believe it that doesn't mean there's going to be adequate downward pressure (in expectation) to prevent an unlucky family from overpaying on the house. (there is upward pressure, though, because of house flipping) and since entry into the agriculture industry is pretty steep, it's not like anyone who has an idea can just build a farm with a cool robust idea that is more optimal than the current solution. the other difficulty is the extensive time horizons to implement the solution suggested by hosh. farmers can't just drop everything they're doing this season, implement regenerative ag ideas today and reap the benefits come harvest this year. it's the same issue with organic. transitioning to organic is a time and cost intensive process for farmers (it can take a few years to be fully certified). only a small percentage of farms produce organic even though it commands a higher price. edit: added this year to end of paragraph 4
- hosh 6y agoThere are some farmers who are already doing it. Like this guy: https://youtu.be/J_htLIUKX1Y https://youtu.be/J_htLIUKX1Y