3 ms·
Is there a reason that the (lower?) courts would keep producing these rulings if the supreme Labour Court has already made the issue clear? Do the judges at tho
by abeppu 6y ago
Is there a reason that the (lower?) courts would keep producing these rulings if the supreme Labour Court has already made the issue clear? Do the judges at those lower courts have reason to believe each case is meaningfully different?
- hugocbp 6y agoThey just do not agree with the Superior court's decision, so they keep giving those rulings knowing full well they will be reverted. Labour Justice is its own court in Brazil. They have their own structure that only judges labour issues and they are usually very protective of employees. My guess is that this is just a form of protest by the first instance judges that do not agree with the ruling. This, unfortunately, is very common in Labour cases in Brazil (at least it was when I stopped being a lawyer there about 3 years ago).