4 ms·
Of course women can handle it. We're all adults. But is it appropriate in context? Is it welcoming? If you have a choice of jobs, is it the kind of environment
by crazygringo 6y ago
Of course women can handle it. We're all adults.
But is it appropriate in context? Is it welcoming? If you have a choice of jobs, is it the kind of environment you prefer?
Or is it contributing to an image of "we're a bunch of immature boys who think it's funny to use a Playboy centerfold, har har, wait till you hear the sexist jokes we tell at lunch".
It's not the end of the world. But a welcoming and inclusive work environment is the sum of hundreds of little things. This is one of those things.
And come on -- the old line "what's the matter, can't you handle a joke?" is the oldest line in the book for "defending" sexist behavior. Expecting women to just "handle something" is not the right approach. We can be better than that.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoTo put a finer point on my comment, I'm claiming that it's not something that needs to be handled. Women can handle it in the same way they can handle a cloudy day or a man not racing over to hold the door open. I would suspect your shrill infantilization of women and the vicarious outrage on the behalf of women is something much harder to handle if you want to minimize the handling women need to do. How many people reading this even saw or knew about the uncropped Lena picture until they saw men on HN/Reddit nodding vigorously at each other over over how many women pass on STEM because of it. I see outrage like yours and wonder when was the last time you actually polled a woman's opinion on something like Lena. I'd wager 95+% of women roll their eyes that a cropped Playboy shot even moves the needle.
- flumpcakes 6y agoThank you. This is very well put. It makes me quite angry to see people racing to remove images or language that at a push could be seen as offensive, to protect groups that don't need or want it. It's insulting to suggest your black co-worker can't use the same language you've always used because you're now saying they are more fragile. It seems to be a race to the bottom in the name of inclusivity and all we're doing is everything but actually improving the opportunities of groups that are "under represented" in CS. Instead of "banning Lenna" how about we create free resources teaching CS skills in a way that will interest women/"others". Does that mean making the slides pink? Solving problems to do with manging boyfriends? No. That's insulting, because women are people like everyone else so stop treating them as fragile brainless creatures that need to be wrapped in cotton wool just to survive in the scary man's world.
- crazygringo 6y agoI don't think I'm the one being shrill here. ;) Unfortunately, your type of attitude is precisely the problem. You deny a problem exists, attack anyone who suggests fixing it, and resort to questioning character and intelligence. I'm sorry that this topic is making you angry. But sometimes it's important to hear other voices. In your case, instead of making a wager, why don't you simply talk to some of your female friends. You don't need to "poll" them, just have a friendly conversation. Don't ask them whether they can "handle" it, but what they would prefer. Your eyes might be opened. I'm talking from actual diverse workplace experiences with issues like this. You don't appear to be, or else I don't think you'd be saying the things you are.
- p1esk 6y agoA woman just commented that it's not a problem: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23797658 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23797658
- klyrs 6y agoAh, tokenism at its finest.
- p1esk 6y agoAh, so you’re suggesting we ignore the opinion of the only woman who showed up in this thread? Ironic, isn’t it?
- klyrs 6y agoHi, I'm a woman too and you can read my opinion on the matter in a nearby comment. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23798157 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23798157 I don't suggest that you take my opinion as the final word, either. It's a complex issue, and nuanced discussion is necessary and should not be vetoed by a single voice. And to be sure, I largely agree with the woman in question: there are much bigger problems at hand. But as stated, the effort level required to discontinue using lena.jpg is zero.
- tehjoker 6y ago>> a man not racing over to hold the door open. It's telling that you think this is something that would even annoy most women, especially in a professional non-dating context. The women I know would feel creeped out if someone did that at work. Honestly, even in dating if you're "racing" to open the door it looks desperate. When done naturally some women like it and some think it's archaic.
- bityard 6y agoI'm sorry you have to endure such an antagonistic social environment. Where I live (midwest US), it's considered polite for all people hold the door open for all others, regardless of gender. I'm a male and if I worked in a place where women sneered at me for holding the door for them, I guess I would start only holding the door for men.
- crazygringo 6y agoHolding the door open for all genders is widely seen as polite and fine, for whoever arrives at the door first, man or woman. It's an optional courtesy. Having a man "race over" to hold a door, and doing so because they're a woman where he wouldn't for another man, in a professional context, is creepy and weird. Do you see the difference? What you're describing in the midwest is fine. But it's not what the parent was responding to. The "antagonistic social environment" with "women sneering" you're describing is a total straw-man of your own imagination.
- ashearer 6y ago> Women can handle it in the same way they can handle a cloudy day Going with that, then why create that cloudy day when it would take very little effort not to? And what message does it send to actively defend creating those cloudy days?
- repiret 6y agoMy first programming job was for a media processing company, and we used the Lena image, and it’s origin was well known, and we were mostly young men so we all found copies of the entire shoot, and they were occasionally involved in office pranks. None of us learned it from HN/Reddit because those weren’t things in 2000. I cannot imagine it was a welcoming environment for women.
- klyrs 6y agohttps://www.losinglena.com/ https://www.losinglena.com/ As a woman in tech, it's actually the discussions surrounding this proposal that I find most telling. The use of Lena is a waterline. Most women (my personal standpoint bias) probably find it inoffensive at face value, and vaguely grating when they learn that it's a centerfold. It's a reminder of a time when porn in the workplace was rather common; one component of a baseline of inescapable sexual harrassment. We've made progress, and sexual harrassment is less socially acceptable now. Some of us would like to erase that waterline, because it's a reminder of an ugly past. But what of the people, mostly men, who cling furiously to using that image? They make me uncomfortable, because it's an indicator of where they stand on pervasive sexual harrassment. Unlike changing terms like master/slave etc, this is a zero-cost proposal (where those are very nearly zero themselves, but more pervasive). Replace the image with something that's got high contrast and color variation. I'd say you can even keep the old name so it won't impact your tooling.
- claudiawerner 6y agoI hope I can weigh in here as a woman (and I do not think my opinion carries any special weight). I don't mind the image, but I definitely do not cling to it - in fact, I wouldn't mind if it's gone at all, and I would treat as suspect someone who continually argues for its place in tech. Engineering is engineering, and porn is porn. That doesn't stop the bizarre campaign linked in your post from being rather hyperbolic. The entire premise is that by removing this one image from common use, "millions of women" (their own phrasing in the trailer) will be empowered to pursue and feel welcomed in tech. The presence of the image (some arguments can be put aside for a moment[0]) is a symptom, not (as far as I can tell) a cause. A campaign like this (and what methods and to whom it is addressed is not clear) would serve better to give a false sense of victory over sexism in tech. Getting the image unused isn't a "small win", I'd say it's detached completely from the battle. A total inversion of the problem, almost comically. [0] Often people argue for things out of sheer principle, not caring much for the specifics of the matter. This is especially common, in my experience, in tech circles. However, there are interesting questions raised vis-a-vis the intersection of meaning, intention, and purpose. It is suspect to cling to 'original meanings' and intentions, and on the basis of that argument, some could well make the argument that the image is empowering as an inversion of traditional morality against sexual expression which still holds sway in conservative groups today. Just as a slave from the 19th c. would understand 'slave' in Git to refer to them, the Victorian puritan would consider the cropped Lena an abhorrent and obscene reference. They would be happy to see the terminology and image gone, but totally miss out on their situational context.
- 2038AD 6y agoI guess the flip-side is that CS is so welcoming and inclusive that tech conferences will invite former sex workers and celebrate them. No slut-shaming from the techies!
- klyrs 6y ago"Booth babes" are not a mark of progress.
- phkahler 6y agoParent comment was talking about Lena, the woman in the picture being discussed.
- 2038AD 6y agoI was referring to Lena being invited to conferences like IS&T's[0] or the ICIP[1]. At photos of both events she is rather older and more modestly dressed (unlike booth babes). [0] http://www.lenna.org/lenna_visit.html http://www.lenna.org/lenna_visit.html [1] https://www.flickr.com/photos/icip2015/22077638933/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/icip2015/22077638933/
- lazyjones 6y ago> is it appropriate in context? Depends on whether you would consider an image very similar to many, many others that get compressed to JPEG is "appropriate" (i.e. relevant, representative), or whether you are asking as a prude. > Is it welcoming? I can't see anything unwelcoming about that picture, at least not in any other way than many people's flattering profile pictures on social media. It's just a head of an attractive woman, shot by a professional photographer.