5 ms·
>> We currently live in a "there is only one correct opinion, all others must be canceled" culture. > We really, really aren't. Perhaps it would be better to
by throwaway894345 6y ago
>> We currently live in a "there is only one correct opinion, all others must be canceled" culture.
> We really, really aren't.
Perhaps it would be better to say that there is a lot of powerful people who are working very hard to create such a culture, but they haven't yet fully achieved their mission. There's no clear definition for when something becomes "a culture of cancellation", but a lot of people are reporting that they are afraid to run afoul of the progressive party line for fear of repercussions. There are of course plenty of people who don't have this fear because they are better protected from progressive reach (either because their industry isn't overwhelmingly progressive or because they have enough power to be okay if the mob comes for them).
> I can't go in to a job interview and call the panel a bunch of cunts and then expect to be hired. That's a consequence of speech "administered outside the law". Does this mean there's no free speech? No, of course it doesn't.
Of course no one is talking about "calling your interviewer a cunt and not getting hired" when they talk about "cancel culture". Name one prominent instance wherein this happened and it was widely condemned as "cancel culture". This seems highly disingenuous.
When people talk about "cancel culture", they're talking about things like:
* a journalist is forced to repent for interview a black person who is happy about the BLM movement but wishes there was more concern about the daily non-police-perpetrated violence in his community
* a data scientist loses his job because he cited a prominent (black) academic's research about the efficacy of nonviolent and violent protests
* a utility company employee loses his job for accidentally making the "OK sign" without even knowing that the left was trolled into considering it to be a white power symbol
* https://twitter.com/wokal_distance/status/1281480650566987776 https://twitter.com/wokal_distance/status/128148065056698777...
> I find it interminably frustrating that people (moreso on the right, and moreso in America, but neither exclusively) hold free speech above pretty much everything else. People have more than ONE right.
“Freedom of expression is the matrix, the indispensable condition, of nearly every other form of freedom.”
—U.S. Supreme Court Justice Benjamin N. Cardozo in Palko v. Connecticut
- joshuamorton 6y agoAssociation is a form of expression. To uphold the freedom of expression is to uphold others' right to stop associating with people. To "cancel" them, if you will.
- throwaway894345 6y agoThat's not what "cancelling" means in this context--we're talking about concerted efforts to have people's employment terminated (or to dox them or send them explicit threats or etc). I don't see how this is anything other than harassment and intimidation, but even if it isn't, hate speech also falls under the rubric of "free expression", but it doesn't mean we can't (or oughtn't) use our own free speech rights to criticize and protest it.
- lliamander 6y agoIt's also potentially tortious interference: https://smallbusiness.findlaw.com/liability-and-insurance/tortious-interference.html https://smallbusiness.findlaw.com/liability-and-insurance/to...
- joshuamorton 6y agoThis seems unlikely. From your link: > For example, Adam could refuse to do business with Bill after learning that Bill has a contract or business relationship with an organization that Adam finds morally distasteful. Adam knows that his business is worth more to Bill than the other organization's and that his refusal to deal is substantially certain to cause Bill to terminate his contractual or business relationship with the other organization. Since his motivation is not improper, Bill's actions would not satisfy a claim of tortious interference by the other organization.
- lliamander 6y agoNot in all cases necessarily, but just read the next line: > On the other hand, if Adam means to punish the other organization or put them out of business by taking the advantages of their relationship with Bill away, it is more likely that a tortious interference has occurred.
- joshuamorton 6y agoThat's an anticompetitive practice. Which makes sense in the context of a tortious interference claim between two businesses. But you can't sue <the collection of 20,000 twitter users> for collectively boycotting a business for doing a thing they disapprove of. If Sleeping Giants is immune to Tortious Interference claims, so is pretty much everyone else in this context.
- M2Ys4U 6y ago>Perhaps it would be better to say that there is a lot of powerful people who are working very hard to create such a culture, but they haven't yet fully achieved their mission. I don't even think that is true. In fact in the overwhelming number of cases cited that I have seen the power dynamic seems to be the other way around. In other words, it's about holding people with more power/privilege/status to account. >There's no clear definition for when something becomes "a culture of cancellation" I agree, which is why I think it's wrong to say that we do live in such a culture. >but a lot of people are reporting that they are afraid to run afoul of the progressive party line for fear of repercussions. I have (some) sympathy for that feeling, but I think most of the time it's unjustified. Like there's some "woke mob" who's coming to cancel you for not realising you're using the wrong pronouns to refer to somebody or something. That... just doesn't happen. >Of course no one is talking about "calling your interviewer a cunt and not getting hired" when they talk about "cancel culture". Name one prominent instance wherein this happened and it was widely condemned as "cancel culture". This seems highly disingenuous. I'm not saying that has actually ever happened. It's an absurd scenario - that was the point - but I concede I may have gone too far. The person I was replying to asserted that "if speech has consequences that are administered outside the law, then it's not really free". Insulting an interview panel is an example of where it would be entirely reasonable for there to be consequences administered outside the law. >“Freedom of expression is the matrix, the indispensable condition, of nearly every other form of freedom.” > >—U.S. Supreme Court Justice Benjamin N. Cardozo in Palko v. Connecticut That just re-enforces my point. Instead of appealing to authority, can you explain WHY is it the matrix of nearly every other form of freedom. HOW is it the matrix for nearly every other form of freedom? In Europe we have a comprehensive rights framework in the form of the European Convention on Human Rights[0]. The Convention includes, amongst others, the right to life (Article 2), the right to a respect for a private and family life (Article 8), and the prohibition of discrimination (Article 14). None of these strictly have a dependency on freedom of expression (Article 10). One of the principles of the ECHR is that rights should not be wielded as to undermine the others (Article 17) and courts must balance rights against each other if they're naturally in competition with each other. I think the American "free speech over everything else" fundamentally stems from the fact that the US doesn't really have (m)any other fundamental rights. When all you have is a hammer... [0] https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/European_Convention_for_the_Protection_of_Human_Rights_and_Fundamental_Freedoms#Section_I_%E2%80%93_Rights_and_freedoms_%C2%B9 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/European_Convention_for_the_P...