4 ms·
Seriously. People wonder why there aren't enough women in CS. Things like the canonical test image being a sexy "come hither" look, coming from a Playboy cente
by crazygringo 6y ago
Seriously. People wonder why there aren't enough women in CS.
Things like the canonical test image being a sexy "come hither" look, coming from a Playboy centerfold, definitely don't help.
And it's not enough to say "well the rest of the centerfold isn't shown". Come on. We all know the source of the image.
And "tradition" is far less important than CS being a welcoming environment for all people.
Computer science is a profession. Let's use images that are appropriate for a professional setting.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThe idea that women can't handle something like the Lena lorem ipsum seems more potentially offputting to women, to me. Seems ironic that guys race over each other to claim a picture of a woman is the shibboleth that keeps women out.
- crazygringo 6y agoOf course women can handle it. We're all adults. But is it appropriate in context? Is it welcoming? If you have a choice of jobs, is it the kind of environment you prefer? Or is it contributing to an image of "we're a bunch of immature boys who think it's funny to use a Playboy centerfold, har har, wait till you hear the sexist jokes we tell at lunch". It's not the end of the world. But a welcoming and inclusive work environment is the sum of hundreds of little things. This is one of those things. And come on -- the old line "what's the matter, can't you handle a joke?" is the oldest line in the book for "defending" sexist behavior. Expecting women to just "handle something" is not the right approach. We can be better than that.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoTo put a finer point on my comment, I'm claiming that it's not something that needs to be handled. Women can handle it in the same way they can handle a cloudy day or a man not racing over to hold the door open. I would suspect your shrill infantilization of women and the vicarious outrage on the behalf of women is something much harder to handle if you want to minimize the handling women need to do. How many people reading this even saw or knew about the uncropped Lena picture until they saw men on HN/Reddit nodding vigorously at each other over over how many women pass on STEM because of it. I see outrage like yours and wonder when was the last time you actually polled a woman's opinion on something like Lena. I'd wager 95+% of women roll their eyes that a cropped Playboy shot even moves the needle.
- flumpcakes 6y agoThank you. This is very well put. It makes me quite angry to see people racing to remove images or language that at a push could be seen as offensive, to protect groups that don't need or want it. It's insulting to suggest your black co-worker can't use the same language you've always used because you're now saying they are more fragile. It seems to be a race to the bottom in the name of inclusivity and all we're doing is everything but actually improving the opportunities of groups that are "under represented" in CS. Instead of "banning Lenna" how about we create free resources teaching CS skills in a way that will interest women/"others". Does that mean making the slides pink? Solving problems to do with manging boyfriends? No. That's insulting, because women are people like everyone else so stop treating them as fragile brainless creatures that need to be wrapped in cotton wool just to survive in the scary man's world.
- crazygringo 6y agoI don't think I'm the one being shrill here. ;) Unfortunately, your type of attitude is precisely the problem. You deny a problem exists, attack anyone who suggests fixing it, and resort to questioning character and intelligence. I'm sorry that this topic is making you angry. But sometimes it's important to hear other voices. In your case, instead of making a wager, why don't you simply talk to some of your female friends. You don't need to "poll" them, just have a friendly conversation. Don't ask them whether they can "handle" it, but what they would prefer. Your eyes might be opened. I'm talking from actual diverse workplace experiences with issues like this. You don't appear to be, or else I don't think you'd be saying the things you are.
- 2038AD 6y agoI guess the flip-side is that CS is so welcoming and inclusive that tech conferences will invite former sex workers and celebrate them. No slut-shaming from the techies!
- klyrs 6y ago"Booth babes" are not a mark of progress.
- phkahler 6y agoParent comment was talking about Lena, the woman in the picture being discussed.
- 2038AD 6y agoI was referring to Lena being invited to conferences like IS&T's[0] or the ICIP[1]. At photos of both events she is rather older and more modestly dressed (unlike booth babes). [0] http://www.lenna.org/lenna_visit.html http://www.lenna.org/lenna_visit.html [1] https://www.flickr.com/photos/icip2015/22077638933/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/icip2015/22077638933/
- lazyjones 6y ago> is it appropriate in context? Depends on whether you would consider an image very similar to many, many others that get compressed to JPEG is "appropriate" (i.e. relevant, representative), or whether you are asking as a prude. > Is it welcoming? I can't see anything unwelcoming about that picture, at least not in any other way than many people's flattering profile pictures on social media. It's just a head of an attractive woman, shot by a professional photographer.
- NoSorryCannot 6y agoFortunate for us that there is a similar race to apologize for erotic photographs in tech demos, as if it's not an obvious anachronism. Really, defending something so clearly out-of-place is deeply suspicious. Maybe everyone can handle it but why are we being asked to?
- flumpcakes 6y agoIf you find Lenna "erotic" and "out-of-place" then you probably shouldn't watch TV or 90% of media. It's a picture of a model's face. You're an adult, deal with it.
- NoSorryCannot 6y agoIt is astonishing that we can't even agree that the photo is erotic. Or that there's a meaningful difference between media you choose to consume for entertainment (which may be honest-to-goodness porn and that's _fine_) and irrelevant eroticism casually sprinkled in tech demos that don't explicitly involve sex. I wish we could at least be real about the facts in evidence.
- minikites 6y agoWhy is it never a sexy/revealing male photo?
- Rebelgecko 6y agoIt's not as common as Lena, but I've seen a lot of papers use a picture of Fabio
- adrianmonk 6y agoOK, time for my pet theory on this. It's not the picture itself that creates an obstacle. It's that emotionally-aware people want to go into a career where they like being around their co-workers. So if they get the impression that many of the people in the field are completely tone-deaf about basic stuff, they start asking themselves questions like, "Since I have limited time on this planet, why would I want to spend it where a good percentage of the people around me are insufferable asshats?" And then they pick some other field. Not because they can't handle it. Because they know they can do better for themselves.
- nisuni 6y agoAs a woman in CS I couldn’t care less about Lena. Let’s focus on real things, not on this phony issues!
- brnt 6y agoPassing an indifference test should however hardly be the right bar to clear for a field of research.
- nisuni 6y agoMy point is: people (often, males) like to speak in the name of all women when it comes to Lena. It’s offensive, it keeps women out of CS, it’s a symbol of the patriarchy, etc... As woman, I am saying this is not the case, at least not for THIS woman: I’ve never felt excluded because of Lena, my CS studies were not impeded by Lena in any way, I have actually used Lena’s image for a small project. Of course I would accept someone saying that the image offends someone (better if this point is substantiated by evidence) but I absolutely reject people speaking in the name of all women, an saying that Lena offends all women. This is not true!
- brnt 6y agoFinding a person not offended does not mean an image does not contribute to a particular environment, or is an example of it. The image need not be offensive to most or even many for it to be true. Also, be careful not to attack a strawman: the issue is of course not just the image. As a man I experienced plenty of unpleasant conversation about women, conversation which might be referred to as men-talk or some such. Also, I'm not competitive at all, while many men would identify that as manly behavior. One of the few women in my university program confided that this (usually unfounded) self-assuredness was very annoying and a huge turn-off, a feeling we both shared, but would have been regarded as an essential ingredient to participating in that program. Of course, such issues are also present in the reverse. My wife had similar conversations but about men amongst some female colleagues. Fortunately, we've met enough people to not have to settle for such juvenile views/conversations. I can absolutely see how a woman would find it very difficult to be comfortable in such an environment however, when I didn't even feel part of that mildly macho culture. Just because something is 'anti-women', does not mean it can only bother women. Our cultures associate many things to gender, which in my view is a leftover of centuries past and we would do well to remove that sort of association. Maybe then, a picture of Lena wouldn't represent a (sub)culture so accurately and be therefore an indicator of the problem.
- anchpop 6y agoI don't have any hard stats, but I'm going to try to talk about my experiences. I took a programming class in highschool - it was almost all boys at the time. This resembles my programming classes in college, and the professional environments I've worked in. Crucially, none of us back in highschool had ever even heard of Lena when we signed up for the class, and I doubt very many of the girls who decided not to take it had heard of Lena either. It feels to me like there's some deeper reason for the gender disparity in tech than Lena. I don't have any issue with changing the picture whatsoever - I'm sure we can find some other picture to use as a baseline (big buck bunny?). But I would be willing to bet that it will do precisely nothing to change the fact that there aren't very many women in CS. I can think of many other factors that seem more plausible to me. Me and my friends were into minecraft - at the time, you installed minecraft mods by overwriting files inside the minecraft.jar. If you wanted to set up a minecraft sever, you were given some command-line program to run and you had to set up port-forwarding in your router. Just doing this stuff makes you more comfortable with computers, and makes the jump to "I want to start programming" seem much smaller than someone who has never stepped outside Chrome and MS Office. And PC gaming is much more popular among young men than young women, so this avenue of becoming comfortable with the computer is going to be much more accessible to men. Not to mention, if you like games, eventually you'll want to make one - I think every PC gamer has at least thought about installing Unreal and trying to make their dreams into reality. I think if we actually want to increase how many women are in CS (and nothing would make me happier), this is the kind of stuff we should be thinking about, not whether image processing programmers use a picture of an attractive woman with bare shoulders too often.
- brnt 6y agoI don't think the argument I'd that stopping using Lena is a silver bullet. The argument is that the image reflects a particular culture, one that not only women, but women in particular on average find uninviting. Personally I have similar feelings about the sexy calenders in some car workshops. It's just a bit too much irrelevant display of ones preferences.