5 ms·
Any article making such a claim need to start with explaining what evidence they have that human brains are not computing devices that can be replicated or simu
by vidarh 6y ago
Any article making such a claim need to start with explaining what evidence they have that human brains are not computing devices that can be replicated or simulated.
Because absent evidence that there is something fundamental preventing us from one day copying the structure of a human brain and ending up with a working device, whatever claims they make are hand-waving.
- enitihas 6y agoI think you missed the main point, replicated economically. Given unlimited budget, I think simulating the human brain might be possible if one could use a powerful enough computer for evey neuron.
- vidarh 6y agoThe article title makes an unqualified claim about realisation, and so it was what I responded to, but the article itself also makes the same strong claim: > A closer look reveals that although development of artificial intelligence for specific purposes (ANI) has been impressive, we have not come much closer to developing artificial general intelligence (AGI). The article further argues that this is in principle impossible, and it revives Hubert Dreyfus’ argument that computers are not in the world. This is not an argument about cost - the article argues that it is "in principle impossible". Any argument about cost I think is also irrelevant: We know from the existence of the brain and how a brain is produced that it is possible to produce one relatively cheaply via biological processes. It seems highly unlikely that our ability to produce an artificial brain will not eventually approach the cost of growing one, because the "worst case" scenario is for us to find ethical ways of growing brain matter via biological processes and hook them up to computers, and it would seem unlikely that we will not eventually find cheaper ways of doing so than growing full mammalian bodies with it, and that we can not find any ways of optimising the process.
- Balgair 6y agoHow the brain grows and develops in humans is not very well understood. We mostly use animal models to understand the nervous system, not humans. As an example of why this is problematic: mouse embryos pretty much turn inside out at day 3, and are the only known mammal to do this. All others, including humans, don't. Why and how are unknown, as are the effects on long term development. Basically, mice are better subjects than zebrafish, but not very good being humans. The limiting factor is not budget or time, but 'stomach'. How elastic are your ethics?
- vidarh 6y agoIt's not very well understood, but the process is known to exist and work. To assume it can't even in principle be replicated would be an extraordinary claim. Yet the article suggests artificial intelligence can not exist even in principle.
- Balgair 6y agoI mean, from a biochem perspective, it's flabbergasting that intelligence exists at all. The brain is so noisy. To me, it's not far fetched to say that you can't make it happen again. Though I think it's technically possible. We're missing something big with intelligence. We know neurons and synapses a little bit. We know a few dozen neurons a little, though it's complexity is crazy big. But that gap between a normal brain down to a few dozen neurons is just boggling right now. There are just so many questions that need to be studied ethically. It may not be possible to answer them all in a reasonable time window.
- chess_buster 6y agoCounter perspective: The process by which the brain produces intelligence might not be complex at all. Maybe it is just a simple algorithm which, when applied en masse, produces it. See for example the neocortex is made up of billions of cortical columns which are all basically the same architecture.
- 6y ago
- blacksqr 6y agoThe author explicitly stated that the main point is that the goal is fundamentally unachievable, regardless of economics or budgets.
- ggggtez 6y agoThe authors main point is bunk if his only defense of that point is that humans are smart. The "learning" problem is solved. We've developed numerous algorithms to take a neural network and have it learn a task. We've solved specific problems, including image recognition, and text synthesis. Companies have figured out how to make sensory equipment including cameras, microphones, touch sensors... Just because no one has managed to put together all the pieces doesn't mean it will never happen. People for thousands of years did not think it was possible to build a flying machine, until someone did.
- blacksqr 6y agoI was not suggesting that I agree with the linked article's argument (I don't). Just that the poster above me misstated the article's main point.
- woeirua 6y agoAh, but this point has yet to be proved to even a small degree. Neural models of very simple organisms do tend to show that adequate connectome models appear to be enough to produce similar behaviors, but we know for a fact that there's a ton of biochemistry going on in the brain that we will not be able to replicate with just the connectome. If I were a betting person, I would wager that the connectome is enough to get something like intelligence, but that without the biochemistry the entire system is unstable in some way. The chemistry that we see in the brain is far more complicated than what would be required to minimally sustain the cells. There's a reason all of this chemistry is going on, and unfortunately I think we're going to find that intelligence just cannot exist as we know it without the chemistry. If that's true, then we're talking hundreds of years before we have computers powerful enough to model the chemistry at the requisite level.
- lurquer 6y ago>Any article making such a claim need to start with explaining what evidence they have that human brains are not computing devices that can be replicated or simulated. If X and Y appear dissimilar, the burden of proof is on he who would argue they are similar. If one contends a brain and a computer and the functions of each appear similar, then one is being disingenuous.
- yellowstuff 6y agoSurely the burden of proof is on someone claiming something is impossible? I skimmed the article but I didn't see any support for his argument beyond pointing to the limitations of existing technology, and asserting that these limits were insurmountable.
- lurquer 6y ago>Surely the burden of proof is on someone claiming something is impossible? You can't prove a negative in this sense. In general, we know things are possible... but we never know if things are impossible. And, don't call me surely.
- michaelmrose 6y agoIf you can't explain what the difference is between computation and thought how can you hope to argue that one can't be used to achieve the other.
- lurquer 6y agoI'm not arguing that it can't. I was merely pointing out the proper 'burden of proof.' The article was criticized for failing to demonstrate that something can't be done... that's not fair. The burden would be on the proponent of the proposition that a machine can attain general AI. That's all. Perhaps there could be general AI... I'm not saying it can't be done. I would point out, though, that IF it is to be done, it certainly won't be by copying a brain. Nobody even knows the hell the brain works...
- blablabla123 6y agoThe Halting Problem definitely puts bounds on what an algorithm can know about another one. At least this should backup the empirical evidence why analytical approaches haven't gotten so far yet.
- vidarh 6y agoI don't know why you think the halting problem is relevant here. The halting problem equally applies to human computation, and it does not preclude our existence.
- jqpabc123 6y agoThere is quite a bit of evidence that your brain is analog, not digital. There is lots of evidence that it is both chemical and electrical in nature And while it is capable of logic, it does not rely strictly on any specific form of logic. In other words, the only working models we have for "intelligence" are nothing like the silicon binary switches we are attempting to use to replicate it.
- Invictus0 6y agoAnalog can be represented in digital: we can mathematically prove this. It's not at all reasonable to say that AGI cannot be achieved because it doesn't use a certain type of material.
- yellowapple 6y agoIn addition to being able to digitally represent analog signals, there's also such a thing as analog computation, including electronic analog computation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_computer#Electronic_analog_computers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_computer#Electronic_ana... So if the brain is an analog computer, then it seems reasonable to believe that we might be able to someday construct an equivalent analog computer (or a digital equivalent thereof).
- vidarh 6y agoYou make the assumption that any computer we'd try to use to replicate it will inherently be digital and electronic. If we prove unable to replicate a brain this way, nothing is stopping us from using biochemical systems instead. Analog computers exists, and we have used bio-mechanical systems for computation... Heck, the first "computers" were humans. Getting hung up on the current preferred paradigm of computation as the only possible one is one of the biggest flaws of the article.