7 ms·
JK Rowling is a good example of middlebrow views getting you and anyone who can be associated with you in trouble. She has widely-held opinions like trans-wome
by hombre_fatal 6y ago
JK Rowling is a good example of middlebrow views getting you and anyone who can be associated with you in trouble.
She has widely-held opinions like trans-women should be respected, but they are different from women. But if you log on to Twitter, she's vilified so much as a "transphobe" that people have been attacked for merely signing the same open-letter that she signed.
https://twitter.com/emilyvdw/status/1280580388495097856 https://twitter.com/emilyvdw/status/1280580388495097856
- mobilejdral 6y ago> She has widely-held opinions like trans-women should be respected Um no. She has admitted to being part of the known trans hate group GenderCritical. Edit: not sure why I am getting downvoted. She uses talking points from the GenderCritial group when she writes and even mentions them by name and that group was banned by reddit for being a hate group.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThis is the sort of vague "argument"-crafting I expect on Twitter but not on HN where you have unlimited words to make a point and add understanding to the world. I googled "jk rowling gender critical" and all I see is a great google query if you want to find articles about how supposedly transphobic she is (without explaining what was specifically transphobic about what she said). If you're going to say someone has admitted to being part of a hate group, why not help us out and provide us some links?
- mobilejdral 6y agoThe recent opinion essay she wrote: https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-her-reasons-for-speaking-out-on-sex-and-gender-issues/ https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-... A rebuttal of that essay with citations: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1270787941275762689.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1270787941275762689.html And an article talking about the banning of the hate subreddit r/gendercritical: https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/06/29/reddit-bann-transphobia-gender-critical-page-hate-speech-donald-trump-steve-huffman/ https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/06/29/reddit-bann-transphobi...
- femiagbabiaka 6y agoJK Rowling is a good example of quite the opposite — someone who uses flowery language to insinuate pretty heinous things about trans people, and then pretend she’s said something innocuous. At any rate, you can’t cancel a multi-millionaire.
- efa 6y agoexample?
- femiagbabiaka 6y agoI wrote out a graf with an example downthread, I'd copy over, but posting the same thing twice feels a little redundant.
- efa 6y agoWell, first of all I disagree that her defense of trans women is disingenuous. Her points are well thought out. She points to specific situations where trans women are vulnerable. Just because she has another concern doesn't invalidate her concern for trans women being vulnerable. So her heinous viewpoint is she has concern for girls in restrooms and locker rooms? Why is she not allowed to have this concern? The rest of the country/world is not San Francisco. Where I live I've never seen anything other than Men and Women restrooms. Sure adding a gender neutral bathroom could help with the issue but they don't exist in the vast majority of locations in the US. I have two high school daughters - one with autism. I'm sorry if its a dangerous trope from half a century ago - but my wife and I would be concerned with a trans woman sharing the locker room with them. Certainly my non-autistic daughter would feel uncomfortable. My daughter with autism wouldn't care because she has trouble with boundaries and being appropriate which makes it more concerning. So now you'll say I don't care about the fate of trans people. Nope. It's possible to have concern for them and concern for non-trans people.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoYou'd have to be more specific about the rest of your post. What exactly is heinous? But the litmus test for whether cancel culture exists isn't whether you can cancel a millionaire, but to see how people react to what she said. Like writing a public letter to your employer to express disapproval for a coworker who signed the same Harper letter. I'll side with Paul Graham on the matter. Here he replies to AOC: https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1281626457693982724 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1281626457693982724 36min ago.
- M2Ys4U 6y agoFor people that have been aware of her it's entirely obvious that Rowling is not engaging in the issue in good faith. For example, before she published under her own name she published under the pen-name of "Robert Galbraith". So far so what, right? Well that's the name of an infamous psychologist who experimented on gay people - often people in the criminal justice system who did not or could not consent to treatment - in order to try and convert them to heterosexuality. Rowling has also been a vocal defender of Maya Forstater who lost a case at the Employment Tribunal in a case about how she described trans people for "[violating] their dignity and/or [creating] an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment". That's not the view of some random trans rights campaigner, that's a judge who must take in to account freedom of expression as provided for in the European Convention on Human Rights. There's much more when you scratch the surface of Rowling's transphobia.