4 ms·
Perhaps worth noting: This is the same John Cleese that has decried London becoming a multicultural city that is "no longer English." https://www.thelondonecon
by shadowgovt 6y ago
Perhaps worth noting: This is the same John Cleese that has decried London becoming a multicultural city that is "no longer English."
https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/john-cleese-is-cancelled-after-he-claims-london-is-no-longer-english/29/05/ https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/john-cleese-is-cancel...
- the-dude 6y agoWhy do you feel this is relevant in the context of PC?
- shadowgovt 6y agoI believe it sheds light on Cleese's definition of both political correctness and intolerance of un-PC attitudes.
- collyw 6y agoWhen the natives make up less than 50% of the population, he might have a point. What does it mean to be English? Nothing more than holding a passport?
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe English complaining about natives losing power would be a bit rich, wouldn't it?
- msla 6y agoI'd make mention of the fact they likely think the English can be British, but they also probably imagine that a good Englishman can eat pork and beef!
- scubbo 6y agoCan you elaborate? What does this mean?
- msla 6y agoIt's a long joke about word etymology relating to how many times the Green and Pleasant Land has been conquered: "Britain" relates to "Briton" which used to mean a Celtic native of the British isles. That is, the people who were there when the Romans showed up. "English" comes from the Angles, one of the Germanic peoples who colonized Britain when the Romans left. Etymologically, being English and British means you're of a mixed parentage indeed, and rather proves the case that immigrants integrate quite well. "Pork" and "beef" come from Norman French, "Norman" from the fact they were originally Vikings and French from the fact they settled in Normandy before expanding their holdings in 1066. Again, proof that modern Great Britain is a land of immigrants, strivers, and hopefuls from across the water, going back to time immemorial.
- ardy42 6y ago>>> I'd make mention of the fact they likely think the English can be British, but they also probably imagine that a good Englishman can eat pork and beef! > "Pork" and "beef" come from Norman French, "Norman" from the fact they were originally Vikings and French from the fact they settled in Normandy before expanding their holdings in 1066. Again, proof that modern Great Britain is a land of immigrants, strivers, and hopefuls from across the water, going back to time immemorial. That's not how I initially interpreted that at all. I had figured "can eat pork and beef" was most likely referring to Hindu and Jewish/Muslim dietary prohibitions.
- scubbo 6y agoWow - an in-depth and interesting joke. I'm glad that I asked - I, like your other replier, thought that "Pork and beef" were a reference to religious dietary restrictions, and had assumed that you were making some obliquely-racist claim that England was now controlled by "those people". I apologise for having misjudged you - thank you for the explanation!
- tptacek 6y agoApart from the gross sentiment that could easily be read from this comment, "natives" do not in fact make up less than 50% of London's population. This whole story is a terrible fit for HN.
- incrimintal 6y agoThe gross sentiment that white people, like every other people, may have their own countries?
- gadders 6y agoWhat's your definition of "native"?
- tptacek 6y agoObviously, born in the UK. What other definition could there be?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- collyw 6y agoObviously? When you talk about "native Americans" you would assume it's more than just being "born there", there would be the assumption of ethnicity and culture included. Likewise with other "natives". Even legally speaking being born in the UK doesn't necessarily make you a British citizen. I am curious why a different definition from what seems to be the norm becomes "obvious" to you.
- roenxi 6y agoI dunno, what are the recent stats? The 2011 census apparently had 37% [0] of London being born outside the UK. It isn't unreasonable statement, particularly on a trend basis natives might be <50% by now. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_London#Ethnic_breakdown https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_London#Ethnic...
- Starkus 6y agoHe's rather right about London and many parts of the EU, Europe has been losing its cultural identity for years.
- gameswithgo 6y agoCultural identity is never lost, but cultural identity is always changing.
- the-dude 6y agoSure, I will have a shot at describing some change. I am a blond male who has a bit of a feminine hairstyle, which imho matches my body type. In the last month I have been called cancer whore ( Dutch: kankerhoer ) twice, this is new for me. However, young females have been called cancer whore for years now, and it is the political correctness which supresses discussion about this. Because that would be racist.
- pjc50 6y agoStreet abuse is never OK regardless of who it's from, you don't have to pretend there's a racial conspiracy to stop you discussing it.
- the-dude 6y agoThanks for the kind words. I am not pretending there is a conspiracy at all. The PC is out in the open.
- shadowgovt 6y agoCan you give some concrete examples of someone being censured for criticizing people being called cancer-whore? It's not out of the realm of possibility, but that seems an extraordinary claim.
- 6y ago
- buboard 6y agoLooks like he is consistent
- jacknews 6y agoThis is a little bit QED. If 'who said it' and 'what views do they hold' is more important than what they're actually saying, then we've become post-rational, and well on our way back to less open and enlightened culture.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIt's not unreasonable to evaluate someone's comments in the context of their past statements on related matters.
- jacknews 6y agoOf course, it's called 'context'. But arguing that previous miss-steps invalidate current arguments is irrational.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shadowgovt 6y agoNo disagreement there. I shared the link to give context.
- Avshalom 6y agoWho said it and what views they hold is important for distinguishing between what they technically said and what they actually said.
- seneca 6y ago> Who said it and what views they hold is important for distinguishing between what they technically said and what they actually said. Would you mind clarifying the difference between the two for me? It sounds an awful lot like we're talking about thought crimes.
- 6y ago
- Wolfenstein98k 6y agoHow is this worth noting at all? Either he's correct or he's not, ad hominem is fallacious. Please engage with ideas on their merits rather than by reading through the author's tweets until you eventually find something unfashionable and unrelated.
- shadowgovt 6y agoBecause the Big Think was recorded in 2016. It's interesting to see where the Big Thoughts have led him in the intervening 3 years. Engaging ideas on their merits isn't the same as engaging them in a vacuum.
- blub 6y agoWhere have the big thoughts led him? Maybe you could post that directly instead of some vague innuendo and save us all some wasted time.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt goes to his definition of "political correctness." It seems that what he feels needs to be culturally protected is his right to make unfunny, inaccurate claims about the nature of London without criticism. While (to my knowledge) nobody says he shouldn't have the right to make such claims, the notion that he's heading towards an "Orwellian nightmare" because people have less tolerance for such inaccurate and unfunny claims and will call him to task for such nonsense is a bit silly.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoIt's unfunny and inaccurate for you; other people might have a different opinion.
- rjkennedy98 6y ago> inaccurate claims What is inaccurate about the claims. The English are an ethnic minority in London. That is a fact. You can say oh Englishness isn't the same as the Ethnic English, but to do that you are stripping English people of their ethnic identity and their culture. > nobody says he shouldn't have the right to make such claims Yes, please do believe that. Lots of them. It may shock you but in much of the world there isn't free speech. Imagine that. Do you think in China you can go around criticizing the government? > people have less tolerance for such inaccurate and unfunny claims and will call him to task for such nonsense is a bit silly No, they are claiming the speech itself is unsafe and trying to cancel people. There is a huge difference which you don't seem to get. And it's not silly. It's primarily about intimidation and fear that if you say the wrong thing you will lose your job, get cancelled, ect. Tolerance to intolerance is not tolerance. I sometimes wonder, do people who think like you actually know how many people died in the so called "cultural revolutions" around the world (such as in China and Russia) which happened during just the last century. It's in the tens of millions. Intellectuals and dissidents rounded up to be killed or put in gulags. People forced to pledge loyalty to causes and leaders and to be re-educated. The cultural revolution leaders in our country have already started to get rid of any kind of meritocracy (racist tests they claim). UC schools functionally banned the tests just recently. My brother was telling me that UCSF med school removed standardized testing from its admissions and in one year the Asian population went from 60% to 20%. Across academia now your ability to get in will be based on your ability to show how you contribute to the goal of diversity (via skin pigmentation of course). But I guess to some it's all silly.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoWell, it's true. So how is that related to the topic we're discussing?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> This is the same John Cleese that has decried London becoming a multicultural city that is "no longer English." That's a weird, centuries-late complaint about the natural consequence of world-spanning empire. You can't just colonize half the world without getting anyone else’s culture in your capital.